MakeMKV support forum
https://forum.makemkv.com/forum/
If @yusesope release the tool, I hope you can do the same comparative for people like me who only have tv and we can't test DV DLRESET_9999 wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2020 1:12 am good news, DL DV TS made by Tsmuxer are the real deal.
identical in real life and so is the screenshots comparison: https://slow.pics/c/V994dhhF
DV, Atmos, Subtitles, and even fast-forwarding now works. this is awesome.
Nice work! if this method plays well on the shield / firestick and other single layer only devices then I could create another one-click app, combining your tool with tsmuxer to make single layer ts files with atmos from m2ts / mkv remux (assuming you're using a win based program that can be ran from a cmd line, I'm guessing mp4 box? ). I've been trying to make one with dvdfab from command line but it's absolutely horrible. here's hoping for good news!yusesope wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2020 7:25 pm Not to be outdone, MAYBE, I found a way to combine the base layer, the enhancement layer (both MEL and FEL) and RPU metadata in a single layer from a dual layer Blu-ray disc.
x700 is becoming enticing. does the ts files also work from a dlna server like plex so you don't need a usb hdd?RESET_9999 wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2020 1:12 am good news, DL DV TS made by Tsmuxer are the real deal.
identical in real life and so is the screenshots comparison: https://slow.pics/c/V994dhhF
DV, Atmos, Subtitles, and even fast-forwarding now works. this is awesome.
Sorry if this is a noob question as I've been trying to follow all the progress being made here lately, but how do you keep both video layers when you do the initial mkv rip in step 1? All the ripped MKVs of DV movies I have only show up with one video layer when imported into tsmuxer. I even verified that the two layers exist on the original m2ts file, but it's just not there on the mkv. The resulting TS mux then only has HDR10 and no DV.built_to_chill wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2020 8:12 pm Ok - I am on cloud 9. I just tried:
1) Game of thrones S8 UHD rip using MakeMKV
2) Extract .thd and convert to .thd+ac3 using eac3to
3) Using tsMuxeR nightly build, imported the two video layers from the mkv created in 1) alongside thd+ac3 created in 2).
It works beautifully on the X700!
- Plays in Dolby Vision (confirmed by pressing info on X700 remote)
- Plays Dolby Atmos. My Denon AVR reports the stream as “Dolby Atmos - TrueHD” and the bitrate is normal (regardless of what mediainfo says).
- Lip sync is perfect! I had a hope this would happen because as I said before - lip sync is perfect whenever playing discs on the X700. It is only LPCM I see the issues.
This is phenomenal. No compromise compared to watching the disc, but with the benefit of it being totally silent from my SSD. Also, far less disc thrashing when creating the files due to no more need for the intermediate MP4.
Within 24 hours I’ve gone from regretting buying the X700 just to play DV files (due to lipsync with LPCM) to witnessing the dawn of (dare I say) an effectively no compromise situation with respect to DV remuxes. And the X700 becoming an invaluable piece of equipment. Wow.
Hi - Id check your using the latest versions of both pieces of software. Although even the stable tsMuxeR shows both video layers for me. But you need the latest “nightly” version from the developers for Dolby vision (linked in the readme on the github project).shawnc22 wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2020 5:08 am
Sorry if this is a noob question as I've been trying to follow all the progress being made here lately, but how do you keep both video layers when you do the initial mkv rip in step 1? All the ripped MKVs of DV movies I have only show up with one video layer when imported into tsmuxer. I even verified that the two layers exist on the original m2ts file, but it's just not there on the mkv. The resulting TS mux then only has HDR10 and no DV.
Excellent, thank youRESET_9999 wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2020 5:26 pmyes, you can revert back to m2ts, ISO or bluray structure.baker99 wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2020 12:22 pm A quick question for the experts, if I remux my m2ts files from a UHD disc to ts can I reverse the process? i.e. using ts muxer to convert the ts back to m2ts will it be exactly the same as the original and work in the UHD disc? I'd rather not keep two copies of the files and waste hard drive space or have to re-rip my UHD discs again when needed.
Brilliant work, I'd wondered where you had vanished too.yusesope wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2020 7:25 pm Hello everyone!
I am happy to see that there have been developments.
I haven't tried the new method (tsMuxeR) yet but it looks promising.
Not to be outdone, MAYBE, I found a way to combine the base layer, the enhancement layer (both MEL and FEL) and RPU metadata in a single layer from a dual layer Blu-ray disc.
I did some tests with the latest Terminator (BL on one layer and FEL + RPU on the other)and HERE you can find some test files.Code: Select all
MPEG-H HEVC Video 48713 kbps 2160p / 23.976 fps / 16:9 / Main 10 @ Level 5.1 @ High / 4:2:0 / 10 bits / 1000nits / HDR10 / BT.2020 * MPEG-H HEVC Video 5128 kbps (9.53%) 1080p / 23.976 fps / 16:9 / Main 10 @ Level 5.1 @ High / 4:2:0 / 10 bits / 1000nits / Dolby Vision FEL / BT.2020
I have created a custom tool (for now, a bunch of disorganized lines of code) and , without using DVDFab, these are the results (files without audio tracks):Code: Select all
Formato : MPEG-4 Nome commereciale : HDR10 Profilo formato : Base Media / Version 2 ID codec : mp42 (mp42/dby1/isom) Dimensione : 78,1MiB Durata : 11s 470 ms Bitrate totale : 57,1 Mb/s Data codifica : UTC 2020-02-27 17:24:54 Data : UTC 2020-02-27 17:24:54 Video ID : 1 Formato : HEVC Formato/Informazioni : High Efficiency Video Coding Nome commereciale : HDR10 Profilo formato : Main 10@L5.1@High Dolby Vision : 1.0, dvhe.04.06, BL+EL+RPU ID codec : hev1 ID codec/Informazioni : High Efficiency Video Coding Durata : 11s 470 ms Bitrate : 57,1 Mb/s Larghezza : 3.840 pixel Altezza : 2.160 pixel Rapporto aspetto visualizzazione : 16:9 Modalità frame rate : Costante Frame rate : 23,976 (24000/1001) FPS Spazio colore : YUV Croma subsampling : 4:2:0 (Type 2) Profondità bit : 10 bit Bit/(pixel*frame) : 0.287 Dimensione della traccia : 78,1MiB (100%) Default : Si AlternateGroup/String : 1 Data codifica : UTC 2020-02-27 17:24:54 Data : UTC 2020-02-27 17:24:54 colour_range : Limited Colori primari : BT.2020 Caratteristiche trasferimento : PQ Coefficienti matrici : BT.2020 non-constant MasteringDisplay_ColorPrimaries : Display P3 MasteringDisplay_Luminance : min: 0.0001 cd/m2, max: 1000 cd/m2 MaxCLL : 1000 cd/m2 MaxFALL : 446 cd/m2 Codec configuration box : hvcC+dvcC+hvcE
Each file is made with a different profile (dvhe.04.06, dvhe.05.06, dvhe.07.06) and all of them are organized in a single Dolby Vision layer (BL + EL + RPU).
The Terminator intro isn't the best way to test this kind of thing, but you can't have it all from life.
As always, let me know!
I'm pretty sure I'm using the latest version of makemkv (1.14.7 Beta?). Are you saying that when you open a UHD disc with DV in makemkv, you see two video tracks under the main title? I've attached a screenshot of what I'm seeing when I tried Black Panther. Looks like just the main HDR10 layer is detected.built_to_chill wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2020 8:47 amHi - Id check your using the latest versions of both pieces of software. Although even the stable tsMuxeR shows both video layers for me. But you need the latest “nightly” version from the developers for Dolby vision (linked in the readme on the github project).shawnc22 wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2020 5:08 am
Sorry if this is a noob question as I've been trying to follow all the progress being made here lately, but how do you keep both video layers when you do the initial mkv rip in step 1? All the ripped MKVs of DV movies I have only show up with one video layer when imported into tsmuxer. I even verified that the two layers exist on the original m2ts file, but it's just not there on the mkv. The resulting TS mux then only has HDR10 and no DV.
Makemkv always shows the two layers for me when I rip a Dolby Vision UHD, and I simply select them both. I’m afraid I cant think why this isn’t the case for you. It’s hard to initially get setup for makemkv and UHDs (you need a special drive) but clearly you’re past that hurdle if you can rip anything at all.
It's the shield. it doesn't support double layer dv. you need to use dvdfab to make a single layer mp4 and then convert that to TS. but apparently it doesn't play right on the shield. however, as I'm sure you've just read above, yusesope's new method for making single layer mp4s play in DV on the shield. so you could then use that mp4 to make a ts with atmos (which is all what my script would do) and hopefully be good to go.shawnc22 wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2020 3:09 pm The resulting file showed up with the 2 DV layers and AC3+Atmos in mediainfo, but was not activating DV or Atmos at all on my 2019 Shield w/Plex or Kodi. Unfortunately I don't have a x700 to try it on, so not sure if the issue is with the file I generated or the Shield. My current set up is Shield -> denon x3600 -> LG B8
are you able to use tsmuxer nightly to turn that mp4 file into a ts and add any old atmos track to see if it all works?mattmarsden wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2020 4:28 pm So as others have said the 05.06 profile works fine in Plex on the 2019 Shield - it would be great to be able to have a play around with the tool, especially as the start of Terminator is difficult to judge colours etc on.