Midway 2019 4K (new BD-J protection?)

[giomania]

I purchased the disc from Best Buy and an cannot even open it, receiving the message: "Failed to open disc".

Edit: Nevermind, I was also receiving the "automatic sdf downloading is disabled or failed" while decrypting message. I used the instructions in this post to fix my DNS: viewtopic.php?f=1&t=17848&start=105#p80230 and am backing up the full disc now. Instead of using Google DNS, I used Cloudfare (1.1.1.1) as the primary DNS and Quad 9 (9.9.9.9) as the backup DNS.

I never really paid attention or noticed that message and have been ripping UHD discs intermittently, but never titles so new. Now that I am "caught up" and ripped a newer title, I looked at the messages to see what may be causing the issue. Thanks to this forum.

[Bagdad48]

After some digging and matching, for those of you who are ripping the raw movie from 4K disc, the title I found to be the accurate one from beginning to end is "Midway_t70". The other files start at different points of the movie but this one starts accurately from the beginning.

[mike admin]

Can you please post the playlist id for this title (look for source file name: xxx.mpls on the right)

[Bagdad48]

Can you please post the playlist id for this title (look for source file name: xxx.mpls on the right)

Title information
Name: Midway
Source file name: 00373.mpls
Duration: 2:18:25
Chapters count: 16
Size: 74.5 GB
Segment count: 1
Segment map: (502,504,503,508,506,507,505)
File name: Midway_t70.mkv

[rdgrimes]

Can you please post the playlist id for this title (look for source file name: xxx.mpls on the right)

Title information
Name: Midway
Source file name: 00373.mpls
Duration: 2:18:25
Chapters count: 16
Size: 74.5 GB
Segment count: 1
Segment map: (502,504,503,508,506,507,505)
File name: Midway_t70.mkv

This is completely different from the title (504) being delivered in Fab, (which is neither here nor there since Fab is failing to deliver a working rip), but it would be nice to see some confirmation of this for the US BB non-steelbook edition.

[SamuriHL]

I ripped and watched 504, which is what dvdfab said was correct for my best buy disc. I used makemkv to rip a folder backup and then another product to rip 504. No issues with payback.

Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

[rdgrimes]

I ripped and watched 504, which is what dvdfab said was correct for my best buy disc. I used makemkv to rip a folder backup and then another product to rip 504. No issues with payback.

Massive sync A-V issues here, will try a MakeMKV generated MKV and see what its like. What did you use to create the file?

[SamuriHL]

I always use CloneBD to create my MKV's from a MakeMKV ripped folder backup. I've been using this method for a long time now.

[rdgrimes]

^^^
I tried that, as well as an MKV ripped directly from the disc by MakeMKV, the results are the same either way (good) and 504 does appear to be a correct playlist. Again, BB purchased non steelbook release.

[scabbard]

504 correct
I tested DV .mp4 version and regular HDR10 makemkv version
Very minor differences in visual quality, a bit more shadow detail in darker scenes that's about it w/DV

[dmillionz]

Can you please post the playlist id for this title (look for source file name: xxx.mpls on the right)

Title information
Name: Midway
Source file name: 00373.mpls
Duration: 2:18:25
Chapters count: 16
Size: 74.5 GB
Segment count: 1
Segment map: (502,504,503,508,506,507,505)
File name: Midway_t70.mkv

I assume this playlist is for Amazon 4K and not BB correct? My UHD is from Amazon.

[Esch30]

I always use CloneBD to create my MKV's from a MakeMKV ripped folder backup. I've been using this method for a long time now.

Slightly off topic, but do you use this method for DTS:X and traditional DTS-HD MA movies? I use the same method for all Atmos discs, but with everything else, the file generated by MakeMKV seems just fine.

[SamuriHL]

Slightly off topic, but do you use this method for DTS:X and traditional DTS-HD MA movies? I use the same method for all Atmos discs, but with everything else, the file generated by MakeMKV seems just fine.

I do, yes. I have NOTHING against MakeMKV or the output (ATMOS in MKV being a given issue), but, I do prefer CloneBD's interface for selecting titles. It's purely a personal preference on how I rip my MKV's. MakeMKV does an excellent job.

[Bagdad48]

Can you please post the playlist id for this title (look for source file name: xxx.mpls on the right)

Title information
Name: Midway
Source file name: 00373.mpls
Duration: 2:18:25
Chapters count: 16
Size: 74.5 GB
Segment count: 1
Segment map: (502,504,503,508,506,507,505)
File name: Midway_t70.mkv

I assume this playlist is for Amazon 4K and not BB correct? My UHD is from Amazon.

No my copy was bought from BB. 4K disc regular packaging.

[speeddemon]

Is this something MakeMKV could fix with a patch?