Dolby Vision now possible through MP4 Mux.

[kazuma]

the path is still 4-2-3 for this? with your dv version 1.5.9?

I dont know, the worfklow order changed a bit in the latest version..
what device do you play DV again?

LG C9 oled.

[RESET_9999]

LG C9 oled.

option 1 (lossless but can be unstable)
mkv P7 input: 7-2-3
bdmv input: 7-2-2

option 2 (quality loss when input is FEL but 100% stable)
mkv P7 input: 4-2-2
bdmv input: 4-1-1

[MartyMcNuts]

Hi all. Stupid question here, but is there a difference between a 1080p DV layer and 2160p DV layer? There is a release I am trying to hybridize and I have the 4K HDR, but only have access to the 1080p Profile 5 DV. Does anyone have any experience with something like that?

As far as I was aware, all DV layers are 1080p. I'm sure someone will correct me if I am wrong...

[legosoff]

Thanks for the reply. How do I re-process, 4) MODE.P= / 2) MODE.2= right?

if your input is a bluray disc folder yes. 7-4-2 or 7-4-3
if it's a P7 mkv then use 7-4-4 or 7-4-5

7-4-1 is only for when you want to mux raw P5/P8 HEVC,AC3,EC3,SRT...

how do i know when it is a profile 7 file?

bluray disc folder yes. 7-4-2 or 7-4-3 excellent. no problem.
But one mkv problem dvhe.08.06, BL+RPU, Blu-ray compatible / SMPTE ST 2086, HDR10 7-4-4 after that, the green screen again. How do I fix it on profile 7? Thank you.

[Ibuprofen]

For MEL discs I have been using this to discard the EL layer and create a base RPU for mp4 encoding.

Code: Select all

dovi_tool -m 2 convert --discard video.hevc 

This thread says that FEL discs need an additional step to remove_mapping that strips out the additional EL processing.
https://github.com/quietvoid/dovi_tool/discussions/168

Can anyone confirm this is needed on FEL discs?

Code: Select all

fel_to_p81.json 
{
"mode": 2,
"remove_mapping": true
}

dovi_tool --edit-config fel_to_p81.json mux --bl bl.hevc --el el.hevc --discard 

I ran both approaches (discard vs remove_mapping) on a FEL disc and the json metadata was quite different.

[RESET_9999]

bluray disc folder yes. 7-4-2 or 7-4-3 excellent. no problem.
But one mkv problem dvhe.08.06, BL+RPU, Blu-ray compatible / SMPTE ST 2086, HDR10 7-4-4 after that, the green screen again. How do I fix it on profile 7? Thank you.

mapping removal is only for Profile 7 input. When input is P8, my script assumes that the mapping was already removed.
I'll check if i can add support for p8 that still have the mapping

[RESET_9999]

Can anyone confirm this is needed on FEL discs?
.

yes thats correct and you should always remove the mapping for FEL to p8

[legosoff]

bluray disc folder yes. 7-4-2 or 7-4-3 excellent. no problem.
But one mkv problem dvhe.08.06, BL+RPU, Blu-ray compatible / SMPTE ST 2086, HDR10 7-4-4 after that, the green screen again. How do I fix it on profile 7? Thank you.

mapping removal is only for Profile 7 input. When input is P8, my script assumes that the mapping was already removed.
I'll check if i can add support for p8 that still have the mapping

I get you, you're right. These films of his were ready on 08.06, BL + RU, apparently there is a problem, and the other films that are there are working fine. It's most dvh.08.06, BL+RU someone did it wrong. I decide to download the Blu-ray disc, solely trusting myself.

[sw5163]

It's most dvh.08.06, BL+RU someone did it wrong. I decide to download the Blu-ray disc, solely trusting myself.

You can just manually remove those additional mapping in that p8 file, saves the redownloading time.
Sometimes I find it difficult to remux Blu-ray disc when there is a single video stream that consists of multiple m2ts files.
So I actually prefer FEL remux version.

This thread says that FEL discs need an additional step to remove_mapping that strips out the additional EL processing.
https://github.com/quietvoid/dovi_tool/discussions/168

Only the first part and remove_mapping of that post is useful, the rest part regarding MMR and polynomial mapping discussion is just me being stupid, please ignore. But I would like to express my thanks to @quietvoid and @RESET_9999 and you all, really teach me a lot.

[RESET_9999]

I decide to download the Blu-ray disc, solely trusting myself.

You could manually fix it as @sw5163 said but starting from the original untouched disc is always the best workflow.

Sometimes I find it difficult to remux Blu-ray disc when there is a single video stream that consists of multiple m2ts files.
So I actually prefer FEL remux version.

Well, that's a bad idea because most of the remux from seamless branching discs on torrent are done incorrectly with makemkv or mkvtoolnix.
The only way to properly remux seamless disc is with DGdemux or Tsmuxer.

btw in my script, you won't even know when the disc is seamless branching, the whole process is automated regardless of the disc.

[sw5163]

Well, that's a bad idea because most of the remux from seamless branching discs on torrent are done incorrectly with makemkv or mkvtoolnix.
The only way to properly remux seamless disc is with DGdemux or Tsmuxer.

btw in my script, you won't even know when the disc is seamless branching, the whole process is automated regardless of the disc.

Interesting, will look into that, thanks!

[dcoke22]

Well, that's a bad idea because most of the remux from seamless branching discs on torrent are done incorrectly with makemkv or mkvtoolnix.
The only way to properly remux seamless disc is with DGdemux or Tsmuxer.

What do you mean by that? Are you suggesting that the way MakeMKV mashes segments together is wrong in some way?

[RESET_9999]

What do you mean by that? Are you suggesting that the way MakeMKV mashes segments together is wrong in some way?

yes unless makemkv was updated, It doesnt remove the gap in the lossless audio track which can cause some playback problems.

[legosoff]

I decide to download the Blu-ray disc, solely trusting myself.

You could manually fix it as @sw5163 said but starting from the original untouched disc is always the best workflow.

Yes, it has already been done, 7 profile is being executed after 7/4/4, the green screen is still again.

[RESET_9999]

Yes, it has already been done, 7 profile is being executed after 7/4/4, the green screen is still again.

then the problem is something else... what movie is it?
also at this point, a sample would be useful