Dolby Vision now possible through MP4 Mux.

[sw5163]

did you try the old tsmuxer version that made fake p5 files?
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ze3VfN ... sp=sharing
if it works then you have your solution and it's much faster than the mp4muxer.

I have just tried it, unfortunately Apple's internal player has very poor compatibility. As far as I know, it only supports mp4 in hvc1 or dvh1 codec. And I don't have other player to test them, sorry.

Oh I don't nesscessarily use mp4muxer. I mentioned it because it's official tool.
I personally use ffmpeg to extract, dovi_tool to mux, and throw them including subtitle to mp4box. mp4box automatically generate P5 dvh1 by default no matter what the real profile is. The speed seems fine, like 5 min for 70G file. So it's not exactly that bad.

[RESET_9999]

Could anyone with an ATV confirm what @manix said please?
if @sw5163 method works, then I'll update the "playback devices sheet" and make a workflow for Apple users in my DoVi_scripts

because we have conflicting information...
viewtopic.php?p=123338#p123338

[ragico]

Could anyone with an ATV confirm what @manix said please?
if @sw5163 method works, then I'll update the "playback devices sheet" and make a workflow for Apple users in my DoVi_scripts

because we have conflicting information...
viewtopic.php?p=123338#p123338

Tested the files cmv29.mp4 and cmv40.mp4 at my friend's who owns the ATV . The test was done using file explorer for mac (app) installed on the Atv and streaming directly from the Pc, so I think that apple internal player was used.
Both files played entirely in Dolby Vision without hassle.
Hope this can help RESET_9999

[RESET_9999]

Thanks but did it have an RPU response?

[ragico]

Thanks but did it have an RPU response?

I saw the light changing frequently from dark to bright on both files.
So I think yes.

[RESET_9999]

I saw the light changing frequently from dark to bright on both files.
So I think yes.

yep, that confirms it , thank you.

[RESET_9999]

Also, I just noticed that the mp4 created by the latest mp4muxer works on the C2 while it's HDR10 only on the C8(we have to use the old mp4muxer).

[sw5163]

Both files played entirely in Dolby Vision without hassle.

Well, guess sometimes we need to break some rules.

Did you guys test infuse?
Theoretically, fake P5(HDR10 bl and RPU) in MKV should also play by infuse.
With mkv, it can have TrueHD, if ATV can properly handle it.

[sw5163]

Also, I just noticed that the mp4 created by the latest mp4muxer works on the C2 while it's HDR10 only on the C8(we have to use the old mp4muxer).

What do you mean? C2's internal player can also play FEL now? I thought only models before CX can do that.

[RESET_9999]

Also, I just noticed that the mp4 created by the latest mp4muxer works on the C2 while it's HDR10 only on the C8(we have to use the old mp4muxer).

What do you mean? C2's internal player can also play FEL now? I thought only models before CX can do that.

No, I'm talking about P8.
the C8 (probably the C7/C9 too) cannot play the DV MP4 created by the latest version of the mp4muxer. We had to use the older/first version of the tool.

[RESET_9999]

With mkv, it can have TrueHD, if ATV can properly handle it.

appleTV should be able to handle "fake p5" mp4 with LPCM.

[staknhalo]

No, I'm talking about P8.
the C8 (probably the C7/C9 too) cannot play the DV MP4 created by the latest version of the mp4muxer. We had to use the older/first version of the tool.

Wonder how/if the dvh1 flag has affected playback compatibility this entire time

[sw5163]

appleTV should be able to handle "fake p5" mp4 with LPCM.

True, so can all the iOS devices. lpcm(7.1), flac(7.1), alac(up to 5.1) works in mp4 container for apple native player.
7.1 loseless on iPhone built in speaker, lol.

[sw5163]

Wonder how/if the dvh1 flag has affected playback compatibility this entire time

Apple being Apple, won't play dvhe or hev1 like the rest of the world. They have extremely poor compatibility internal player.

Conspiracy theory: Apple absolutely has the ability to support other formats. However, people now need to purchase 3rd party APP like infuse to play other formats. Apple can take 20% through the App Store purchase. So they refused to support other formats.(don't take this seriously)

[chros]

Also, I just noticed that the mp4 created by the latest mp4muxer works on the C2 while it's HDR10 only on the C8(we have to use the old mp4muxer).

Interesting, thanks!