Feature Suggestion: Segment selection

[trumpet205]

I suggest that MakeMKV allows one to pick segment within a specific title.

I'm trying to rip my own copy of Star Trek Next Generation, Season 1, Disc 1. Two titles that share the same segment failed to ripped. I suspect that shared segment is either the opening or credit.

Code: Select all

Saving 2 titles into directory D:/ using profile 'FLAC' from file 'C:\Program Files (x86)\MakeMKV/flac.mmcp.xml'
AV synchronization issues were found in file 'D://title01.mkv' (title #2)
AV sync issue in stream 1 at 0:00:00 with duration of 792.455ms : audio gap was filled with silence
DEBUG: Code 0 at O_h|[Z2T<;A(7V><K1g:213132744
DEBUG: Code 0 at O_h|[Z2T<;A(7V><K1g:213137367
DEBUG: Code 0 at O_h|[Z2T<;A(7V><K1g:213135021
DEBUG: Code 0 at A/9!yS5V6wwwyK2O&Z `:29395057
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4(yOYXRk(~=y3s-rF"jD,:213135090
DEBUG: Code 20 at pb2S`[J>e5XrCCC{:29395379
DEBUG: Code 0 at pb2S`[J>e5XrCCC{:213133227
DEBUG: Code 0 at bd\[Kd6uTi,QKe730o}M:29393286
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4(yOYXRk(~=y3s-rF"jD,:213135090
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 1 to file D://title01.mkv
DEBUG: Code 0 at O_h|[Z2T<;A(7V><K1g:213132744
DEBUG: Code 0 at O_h|[Z2T<;A(7V><K1g:213137367
DEBUG: Code 0 at O_h|[Z2T<;A(7V><K1g:213135021
DEBUG: Code 0 at A/9!yS5V6wwwyK2O&Z `:29395057
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4(yOYXRk(~=y3s-rF"jD,:213135090
DEBUG: Code 20 at pb2S`[J>e5XrCCC{:29395379
DEBUG: Code 0 at pb2S`[J>e5XrCCC{:213133227
DEBUG: Code 0 at bd\[Kd6uTi,QKe730o}M:29393286
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4(yOYXRk(~=y3s-rF"jD,:213135090
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 2 to file D://title02.mkv
0 titles saved, 2 failed

Title 01 uses segment 2 and 64, while title 02 uses 1 and 64. Since error code is the same for both titles by excluding segment 64 I should be able to rip them without error.

If that is not possible, how about keeping the mkv file rather than deleting them right after an error was encountered? That way I can re-encode to trim off problematic section.

[ndjamena]

That has absolutely nothing to do with segments, it's a bug in the latest version of MakeMKV that affects quite a lot of Blu Rays. Use 1.8.9 instead and it should work.


That said, 'Split by Chapters' has been on the request list forever, 'Split by MT2S' is there too, which is pretty much the same thing. So far nothing has been done about either and maybe nothing ever will.