MakeMKV support forum
https://forum.makemkv.com/forum/
not with the tsmuxer. do not be angry with me but read the thread completelydarrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 8:16 am Is it possible to create single layer DV from .m2ts file from STREAM folder?
With HW or HW+ ?parapata wrote: Wed Apr 29, 2020 12:20 pm 1 makemkv
2 TsMuxer dvhe.04 (ts)
3 Nvdia shield 2019 pro
4 Mx pro
Perfect DV-ATMOS-SUBT
In MX Player you can select Hardware (HW) or Hardware+ (HW+) decoders. Which one is set when you play it back?
Today, I've set up a plex server and tried to playback a DV .ts file on my Android Philips Oled Dolby Vision TV. It just doesn't work. ALso Plex doesn't detect Atmos at all in any containers!!! It never has.olevelo wrote: Wed Apr 29, 2020 10:39 pmDon't you need the paid version of plex to do DV? I thought it was only available in beta which is only available to subscribers?rosavanwinkle wrote: Wed Apr 29, 2020 8:30 pmmx pro the payed app? may i ask why not plex?box4m wrote: Wed Apr 29, 2020 7:00 pm
tsmuxer doesnt seem to recognize atmos tracks, it ignores them and i get an error that it cant read it
No internal television application, including Plex, will work with TrueHD atmos tracks. The Shield is the only device capable of direct playing atmos tracks in Plex.darrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 5:58 pmToday, I've set up a plex server and tried to playback a DV .ts file on my Android Philips Oled Dolby Vision TV. It just doesn't work. ALso Plex doesn't detect Atmos at all in any containers!!! It never has.olevelo wrote: Wed Apr 29, 2020 10:39 pmDon't you need the paid version of plex to do DV? I thought it was only available in beta which is only available to subscribers?
Of course, otherwise what's the point of going through all this trouble to get truehd atmos into a container?rosavanwinkle wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:03 pm I'm starting to notice something.
I have a question,do you guys have the right "gear" to play the atmos audio?
aka
A Blu-ray Player/Streaming Player.
A Dolby Atmos AVR.
dolby atmos enabled Speakers.
On my Philips OLED TV with MX Player I can perfectly playback Atmos in MKV Container and also Disney+ And Netflix playback Atmos and Dolby Vision as well.shawnc22 wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:34 pmNo internal television application, including Plex, will work with TrueHD atmos tracks. The Shield is the only device capable of direct playing atmos tracks in Plex.darrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 5:58 pmToday, I've set up a plex server and tried to playback a DV .ts file on my Android Philips Oled Dolby Vision TV. It just doesn't work. ALso Plex doesn't detect Atmos at all in any containers!!! It never has.olevelo wrote: Wed Apr 29, 2020 10:39 pm
Don't you need the paid version of plex to do DV? I thought it was only available in beta which is only available to subscribers?
Of course, otherwise what's the point of going through all this trouble to get truehd atmos into a container?rosavanwinkle wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:03 pm I'm starting to notice something.
I have a question,do you guys have the right "gear" to play the atmos audio?
aka
A Blu-ray Player/Streaming Player.
A Dolby Atmos AVR.
dolby atmos enabled Speakers.
As a standalone player, the shield obviously does not have the same decoders as your TV. If your TV is capable of outputting atmos tracks in mkv, I'm guessing they're not TrueHD lossless atmos, but instead the compressed dolby digital+ version that's also found within streaming apps (Disney+ & Netflix). Especially since none of the Philip's OLEDS have e-ARC, I don't see how it can possibly be passing lossless atmos tracks to your AVRdarrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:55 pmOn my Philips OLED TV with MX Player I can perfectly playback Atmos in MKV Container and also Disney+ And Netflix playback Atmos and Dolby Vision as well.shawnc22 wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:34 pmNo internal television application, including Plex, will work with TrueHD atmos tracks. The Shield is the only device capable of direct playing atmos tracks in Plex.darrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 5:58 pm
Today, I've set up a plex server and tried to playback a DV .ts file on my Android Philips Oled Dolby Vision TV. It just doesn't work. ALso Plex doesn't detect Atmos at all in any containers!!! It never has.
Of course, otherwise what's the point of going through all this trouble to get truehd atmos into a container?rosavanwinkle wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:03 pm I'm starting to notice something.
I have a question,do you guys have the right "gear" to play the atmos audio?
aka
A Blu-ray Player/Streaming Player.
A Dolby Atmos AVR.
dolby atmos enabled Speakers.
Why should Schield TV be better? I assume it has the same software and same decoders.
I'd never buy a Shield TV. It look cheap and take up space on my shelf, haha
You're right it has no e-ARC but it has a dolby atmos soundbar, which I know is crap,but the Atmos Codec is supported internally: https://www.avforums.com/products/oled- ... 935/specs/shawnc22 wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 7:09 pmAs a standalone player, the shield obviously does not have the same decoders as your TV. If your TV is capable of outputting atmos tracks in mkv, I'm guessing they're not TrueHD lossless atmos, but instead the compressed dolby digital+ version that's also found within streaming apps (Disney+ & Netflix). Especially since none of the Philip's OLEDS have e-ARC, I don't see how it can possibly be passing lossless atmos tracks to your AVRdarrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:55 pmOn my Philips OLED TV with MX Player I can perfectly playback Atmos in MKV Container and also Disney+ And Netflix playback Atmos and Dolby Vision as well.shawnc22 wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:34 pm
No internal television application, including Plex, will work with TrueHD atmos tracks. The Shield is the only device capable of direct playing atmos tracks in Plex.
Of course, otherwise what's the point of going through all this trouble to get truehd atmos into a container?
Why should Schield TV be better? I assume it has the same software and same decoders.
I'd never buy a Shield TV. It look cheap and take up space on my shelf, haha
Well that's certainly something different, a TV with a built in "atmos" soundbar? So even if the TV is advertised as being able to handle truehd atmos tracks, the only device it can output it to without eARC is this soundbar. I'm glad you recognize it as a load of crap, but if you insist, the first thing I would try is to do is a straight container conversion from your MKV with a truehd atmos track to a TS container. You can do this with ffmpeg: ffmpeg -i movie.mkv -c copy movie.ts. This resulting file will not have DV, but the atmos track will be without an AC3 core, the same one found in mkv remuxes. If this file plays with atmos on your TV, then the issue is likely to be with TSMuxer. If the file doesn't play, and you're positive that the mkv file with truehd atmos plays, then the issue is likely to be with the TS container itself.darrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 8:54 pmYou're right it has no e-ARC but it has a dolby atmos soundbar, which I know is crap,but the Atmos Codec is supported internally: https://www.avforums.com/products/oled- ... 935/specs/shawnc22 wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 7:09 pmAs a standalone player, the shield obviously does not have the same decoders as your TV. If your TV is capable of outputting atmos tracks in mkv, I'm guessing they're not TrueHD lossless atmos, but instead the compressed dolby digital+ version that's also found within streaming apps (Disney+ & Netflix). Especially since none of the Philip's OLEDS have e-ARC, I don't see how it can possibly be passing lossless atmos tracks to your AVRdarrrkmanxxx wrote: Thu Apr 30, 2020 6:55 pm
On my Philips OLED TV with MX Player I can perfectly playback Atmos in MKV Container and also Disney+ And Netflix playback Atmos and Dolby Vision as well.
Why should Schield TV be better? I assume it has the same software and same decoders.
I'd never buy a Shield TV. It look cheap and take up space on my shelf, haha