www.makemkv.com

DaMacFunkin wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 7:10 am

tr000 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 1:16 am 1917 worked great after ripping the BL, EL with TSMuxer, and using Profile 5 with MP4Muxer. It was, hands down, the best visual experience I've had in terms of Dolby Vision. Everyone that has DV needs to see it.

I agree, I calibrated my LG c9 last weekend and I wasn’t too sure about the Dolby Vision profile that Calman autocal created, till I watched 1917... brilliantly graded.

shawnc22 wrote: Thu Mar 26, 2020 7:02 pm unfortunately I don't understand the subject enough to know what really goes into differentiating between a profile 5 and 8 video. This is definitely not a permanent solution, but maybe @jcdr can consider implementing a user defined dv-profile parameter in a future version of tsmuxer similar to mp4muxer?

tr000 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 1:16 am 1917 worked great after ripping the BL, EL with TSMuxer, and using Profile 5 with MP4Muxer. It was, hands down, the best visual experience I've had in terms of Dolby Vision. Everyone that has DV needs to see it.

DaMacFunkin wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 7:10 am

tr000 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 1:16 am 1917 worked great after ripping the BL, EL with TSMuxer, and using Profile 5 with MP4Muxer. It was, hands down, the best visual experience I've had in terms of Dolby Vision. Everyone that has DV needs to see it.

I agree, I calibrated my LG c9 last weekend and I wasn’t too sure about the Dolby Vision profile that Calman autocal created, till I watched 1917... brilliantly graded.

jcdr428 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 1:14 pm

shawnc22 wrote: Thu Mar 26, 2020 7:02 pm unfortunately I don't understand the subject enough to know what really goes into differentiating between a profile 5 and 8 video. This is definitely not a permanent solution, but maybe @jcdr can consider implementing a user defined dv-profile parameter in a future version of tsmuxer similar to mp4muxer?

I prefer to leave the profile selection as automatic.
I understood that profile 8 is when there is backward compatibility with non-DV players (eg HDR10, SDR...), which is the case with the Blu-ray base layer. However the Blu-ray DVs muxed to single track DV are not fully compliant with profile 8 because of the chroma sample location, which might explain why the player chokes on these. I will push a fix to tsMuxer to change to profile 5.

Edit: Pull request pending merge.

shawnc22 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 3:29 pm Much appreciated for the hard work @jcdr428!

@DaMacFunkin, if you have the Oppo, can’t you just play things straight from a decrypted folder backup/iso? That’ll give you DV and Atmos without having to bother with any remuxing, no?

DaMacFunkin wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 5:12 pm

shawnc22 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 3:29 pm Much appreciated for the hard work @jcdr428!

@DaMacFunkin, if you have the Oppo, can’t you just play things straight from a decrypted folder backup/iso? That’ll give you DV and Atmos without having to bother with any remuxing, no?

Yes, that works fine, but not on Shield, I’m after a solution that works on both so I don’t need 2 rips of the same disk.

DaMacFunkin wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 7:35 am Hi, can confirm this mux of 1917 that didn’t work on the Oppo works in Dolby Vision and Atmos on 2019 shield pro, shame I will have to have 2 muxes of some FEL movies till it’s sorted, particularly because the Oppo is a better picture, the Colours are more balanced.

Is there any other way to try and mux so we get a file that works on both?

Regards.

yusesope wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:16 pm

DaMacFunkin wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 7:35 am Hi, can confirm this mux of 1917 that didn’t work on the Oppo works in Dolby Vision and Atmos on 2019 shield pro, shame I will have to have 2 muxes of some FEL movies till it’s sorted, particularly because the Oppo is a better picture, the Colours are more balanced.

Is there any other way to try and mux so we get a file that works on both?

Regards.

I'm sorry but at the moment I don't have any other ideas.
The strange thing is that the video bit rate of 1917 is 0kbps.
If the cobination of my tool + tsMuxeR worked for Mission Impossible, it may also work for other FEL titles.
You should make some attempts.


I thank those who have tried the files that I modified (by patching the output of FFmpeg ) but at the moment the whole process consumes too much time (so it is useless).

yusesope wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:16 pm

DaMacFunkin wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 7:35 am Hi, can confirm this mux of 1917 that didn’t work on the Oppo works in Dolby Vision and Atmos on 2019 shield pro, shame I will have to have 2 muxes of some FEL movies till it’s sorted, particularly because the Oppo is a better picture, the Colours are more balanced.

Is there any other way to try and mux so we get a file that works on both?

Regards.

I'm sorry but at the moment I don't have any other ideas.
The strange thing is that the video bit rate of 1917 is 0kbps.
If the cobination of my tool + tsMuxeR worked for Mission Impossible, it may also work for other FEL titles.
You should make some attempts.


I thank those who have tried the files that I modified (by patching the output of FFmpeg ) but at the moment the whole process consumes too much time (so it is useless).

tr000 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 9:56 pm

yusesope wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:16 pm

DaMacFunkin wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 7:35 am Hi, can confirm this mux of 1917 that didn’t work on the Oppo works in Dolby Vision and Atmos on 2019 shield pro, shame I will have to have 2 muxes of some FEL movies till it’s sorted, particularly because the Oppo is a better picture, the Colours are more balanced.

Is there any other way to try and mux so we get a file that works on both?

Regards.

I'm sorry but at the moment I don't have any other ideas.
The strange thing is that the video bit rate of 1917 is 0kbps.
If the cobination of my tool + tsMuxeR worked for Mission Impossible, it may also work for other FEL titles.
You should make some attempts.


I thank those who have tried the files that I modified (by patching the output of FFmpeg ) but at the moment the whole process consumes too much time (so it is useless).

I missed a couple pages of history, so forgive my ignorance, but what's the difference with your tool vs. just ripping the BL, EL, and audio with TSMuxer and using Dolby's MP4Muxer with a respective profile to produce an .MP4? Does it allow for lossless audio or something?

I also noted that 0kbps thing—DVDFab BDInfo has been showing that for a lot of DV discs.

Angryunibrow wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 10:19 pm

tr000 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 9:56 pm

yusesope wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 6:16 pm
I'm sorry but at the moment I don't have any other ideas.
The strange thing is that the video bit rate of 1917 is 0kbps.
If the cobination of my tool + tsMuxeR worked for Mission Impossible, it may also work for other FEL titles.
You should make some attempts.


I thank those who have tried the files that I modified (by patching the output of FFmpeg ) but at the moment the whole process consumes too much time (so it is useless).

I missed a couple pages of history, so forgive my ignorance, but what's the difference with your tool vs. just ripping the BL, EL, and audio with TSMuxer and using Dolby's MP4Muxer with a respective profile to produce an .MP4? Does it allow for lossless audio or something?

I also noted that 0kbps thing—DVDFab BDInfo has been showing that for a lot of DV discs.

Correct, no Atmos in .mp4 container.

tr000 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 10:22 pm

Angryunibrow wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 10:19 pm

tr000 wrote: Sat Mar 28, 2020 9:56 pm
I missed a couple pages of history, so forgive my ignorance, but what's the difference with your tool vs. just ripping the BL, EL, and audio with TSMuxer and using Dolby's MP4Muxer with a respective profile to produce an .MP4? Does it allow for lossless audio or something?

I also noted that 0kbps thing—DVDFab BDInfo has been showing that for a lot of DV discs.

Correct, no Atmos in .mp4 container.

Thanks for the reply—what's all this business about the enhancement layers as well? MEL/FEL? Apparently TSMuxer strips one? Just want to be sure I'm not missing anything when I'm making my (non-Atmos) MP4s. My TV can only do up to E-AC3 anyway.