Star Wars 4Ks

[Simbo]

Thanks for the reply.

Each disc appears to have 4/5 streams of the film. So far I have ripped the first stream with EVERY subtitle track and the one I want didn’t appear....that’s why I’m so confused.

[Woodstock]

The streams with 00800 in their name are the "right" ones for English. Within them, the "foreign audio only" English tracks varied from 4 to 7 over series. Usually the first track is the complete English subtitles.

[Simbo]

Thanks. I’m going to give it another whirl tomorrow so fingers crossed I find the sub track that I need.

[MartyMcNuts]

Thanks. I’m going to give it another whirl tomorrow so fingers crossed I find the sub track that I need.

I bought all mine (4K Australian) seperately as they were on sale at JB HiFi, so I saved a bundle! Anyway, I found that for all of them, playlist 00004 is the correct English one with foreign subtitles. I just double checked Attack of the Clones and yes, 00004 is correct and the subtitle appeared at 5:12.

[Simbo]

Thanks all for your replies on this subject.

My mistake was ripping the incorrect stream. I rewatched my rip and realised the intro text wasn’t in English. I found the English stream, re-ripped and the subtitles are in fact hardcoded.

As Woodstock said the correct English stream is the one labelled ‘800’.

[preserve]

Wondering if anyone who has non-US discs - especially UK - can comment on whether they're any different than the US ones? I'm so pleased that just as with Blu-rays, 4K releases in different countries can be quite different (see: The Fifth Element, though that wasn't a simultaneous release). Finally getting around to this and deciding what to buy.

Seeing specs for many of the US discs over at Blu-ray.com but not for the non-US ones. US ones all appear to be only BD-66s, UK don't mention, although the Skywalker Saga set does say those are all BD-66s, so I suppose they could just be the same.

US bitrates reported as:
- Episode I - 44.78
- Episode III - 43.84
- Episode IV - 47.81
- Episode V - 49.89
- Rogue One - 46.65

[Trickyd-1]

I've only got IV V and VI individually purchased UK versions and the reported bitrates (MediaInfo) are:

IV - 47.8 Mb/s
V - 49.7 Mb/s
VI - 42.0 Mb/s

From memory there were only three main feature playlists on the disc, each having different start credits written in EN FR and DE languages.

[preserve]

Thanks! Sounds like they're pretty much the same then, maybe just some minor variation as for which localizations of the intros were done.

[dividido]

Looks like I found the culprit.
I am using a Unifi USG router. I have some Geo blocking in place. The Russian Federation was blocked. the keys pulled by Make MKV are coming from an IP located in Russia. I removed the block on Russia and restarted and now my rips are working.

Hope this helps some

Thanks this was the fix for me! Kudos.

[ghost rider]

I ordered the whole lot of them from Best Buy. I'm pretty new at this and the only ones I've had issues with were bad discs.Funny but the ones I had that wouldn't rip would play in my Oppo maybe a defect I didn't see while watching but hung up the rip. It weird nothing looks scratched but when I get a new one it works. From reading this thread there is a good chance I may have a few issues. I have to rip all 11 movies within 2 weeks or I may have issue with Best Buy's return, I'm thinking.


It's doubtful I'm going to be able to watch more than a few in 2 weeks So as long as the main title (800) will rip without errors I should have a good disc and no need to force myself to watch them all.

Oh and BB has the individual movies for half off $15 for each and $19 for the last jedi.

[A.RABID.BUFFALO]

I ordered the whole lot of them from Best Buy. I'm pretty new at this and the only ones I've had issues with were bad discs.Funny but the ones I had that wouldn't rip would play in my Oppo maybe a defect I didn't see while watching but hung up the rip. It weird nothing looks scratched but when I get a new one it works. From reading this thread there is a good chance I may have a few issues. I have to rip all 11 movies within 2 weeks or I may have issue with Best Buy's return, I'm thinking.


It's doubtful I'm going to be able to watch more than a few in 2 weeks So as long as the main title (800) will rip without errors I should have a good disc and no need to force myself to watch them all.

Oh and BB has the individual movies for half off $15 for each and $19 for the last jedi.

You could try cleaning the discs, glasses cleaner and a microfiber cloth. Most discs still have chemical residue on them from the factory, and I know for a fact when they come in those cardboard slips (don't get me started on them) they are more likely to have issues ripping. But the collectors set for sure had a bad run, I had to return my 1st set to Best Buy wouldn't rip or play in any Blu Ray player I had.

[ghost rider]

I ordered the whole lot of them from Best Buy. I'm pretty new at this and the only ones I've had issues with were bad discs.Funny but the ones I had that wouldn't rip would play in my Oppo maybe a defect I didn't see while watching but hung up the rip. It weird nothing looks scratched but when I get a new one it works. From reading this thread there is a good chance I may have a few issues. I have to rip all 11 movies within 2 weeks or I may have issue with Best Buy's return, I'm thinking.


It's doubtful I'm going to be able to watch more than a few in 2 weeks So as long as the main title (800) will rip without errors I should have a good disc and no need to force myself to watch them all.

Oh and BB has the individual movies for half off $15 for each and $19 for the last jedi.

You could try cleaning the discs, glasses cleaner and a microfiber cloth. Most discs still have chemical residue on them from the factory, and I know for a fact when they come in those cardboard slips (don't get me started on them) they are more likely to have issues ripping. But the collectors set for sure had a bad run, I had to return my 1st set to Best Buy wouldn't rip or play in any Blu Ray player I had.

A new hope just completed, with a couple sync errors. I guess it's ok.

a new hope.jpg (267.13 KiB) Viewed 83512 times

[ghost rider]

Empire strikes back failed and Return of the jedi had 8 of those audio skew errors but it finished.

[ghost rider]

I cleaned return of the jedi again this time with a dawn and warm water. I got the same errors. Is this a bad disc?

[A.RABID.BUFFALO]

I cleaned return of the jedi again this time with a dawn and warm water. I got the same errors. Is this a bad disc?

Do you have advance settings enabled? Turn those off and see if you see the same error messages.