Salt (2010) Cinema, Director's and Extended Cut

[mgutt]

This is regarding the steelbox of Salt in German. It contains all three Cuts in different length:

Director's Cut

Titelinformationen
Name: Salt (English)
Name der Quelldatei: 00003.mpls
Länge: 1:44:04
Anzahl der Kapitel: 16
Size: 25.7 GB
Segmentanzahl: 28
Segmentkarte: 11,143,114,144,116,145,118,146,120,147,122,148,124,149,126,150,128,151,130,152,132,154,134,155,136,157,138,159
Name der Ausgabedatei: Salte00.mkv
Titelinformationen
Name: Salt (English)
Name der Quelldatei: 00004.mpls
Länge: 1:44:04
Anzahl der Kapitel: 16
Size: 25.7 GB
Segmentanzahl: 28
Segmentkarte: 11,143,114,144,116,145,118,146,120,147,122,148,124,149,126,150,128,151,130,152,132,154,134,155,136,157,138,159
Name der Ausgabedatei: Salte03.mkv

Extended Cut

Titelinformationen
Name: Salt (English)
Name der Quelldatei: 00005.mpls
Länge: 1:41:04
Anzahl der Kapitel: 16
Size: 25.1 GB
Segmentanzahl: 28
Segmentkarte: 11,143,114,144,116,145,118,146,120,147,122,148,124,149,126,150,128,151,130,153,132,154,134,156,136,158,138,160
Name der Ausgabedatei: Salte01.mkv
Titelinformationen
Name: Salt (English)
Name der Quelldatei: 00006.mpls
Länge: 1:41:04
Anzahl der Kapitel: 16
Size: 25.1 GB
Segmentanzahl: 28
Segmentkarte: 11,143,114,144,116,145,118,146,120,147,122,148,124,149,126,150,128,151,130,153,132,154,134,156,136,158,138,160
Name der Ausgabedatei: Salte04.mkv

Cinema Cut

Titelinformationen
Name: Salt (English)
Name der Quelldatei: 00002.mpls
Länge: 1:39:59
Anzahl der Kapitel: 16
Size: 24.8 GB
Segmentanzahl: 28
Segmentkarte: 11,113,114,115,116,117,118,119,120,121,122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131,132,133,134,135,136,137,138,139
Name der Ausgabedatei: Salte02.mkv
Titelinformationen
Name: Salt (English)
Name der Quelldatei: 00040.mpls
Länge: 1:39:59
Anzahl der Kapitel: 28
Size: 24.8 GB
Segmentanzahl: 28
Segmentkarte: 11,113,114,115,116,117,118,119,120,121,122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131,132,133,134,135,136,137,138,139
Name der Ausgabedatei: Salte05.mkv

I only need the Director's Cut. As you can see it is part of 00003.mpls and 00004.mpls. Both contain the same segment parts, chapters, etc:

2019-06-05 09_02_50.jpg (90 KiB) Viewed 8371 times

2019-06-05 09_03_27.jpg (92.49 KiB) Viewed 8371 times

but the file size differs a little bit:
Salte00.mkv - 00003.mpls - 23.126.528.622 Bytes
Salte03.mkv - 00004.mpls - 23.126.292.734 Bytes

I checked the credits and intro but can not see any difference. As the segments are identical this seems to be logic. Which differences could be left?

[mgutt]

I tried to check the audio. By that I used gMKVExtractGUI and extracted the audio tracks, subtitle sup and chapter xml files.

The differences as follows:

Through PSPad I found that chapters contain different "EditionUID" and "ChapterUID" :

2019-06-05 09_18_17.jpg (63.72 KiB) Viewed 8370 times

The HashCheck Shell Extension shows identical english DTS-HD MA audio tracks:

2019-06-05 09_21_01.jpg (58.13 KiB) Viewed 8370 times

Then I compared all subtitle files (English and German) and found different checksums for two subtitle files:

2019-06-05 09_27_59.jpg (126.79 KiB) Viewed 8370 times

In the next step I will search for a tool to check the sup-files content as they seem to be encrypted or compressed.

[mgutt]

Now I used Subtitle Edit 3.5.9 to convert the SUP (text as images) file to SRT (text is OCR'd through Subtitle Edit). I checked the differences with PSPad again and its American vs British English:

2019-06-05 09_51_39.jpg (26.75 KiB) Viewed 8370 times

Wow. So much work for this little detail

Result:
Salte00.mkv - 00003.mpls - American English
Salte03.mkv - 00004.mpls - British English

I'll go with AE.

Maybe MakeMKV could highlight differences like this in the future?

[Haui111]

Hi there! Thanks fos doing all this work! I just broke my head trying to figure out what was wrong with this movie and your explanations we're aweseome even years later!