Failed to rip Avatar (US Region) with 1.5.4

[50CalAL]

Wasn't sure if we needed separate threads for this movie but I'm also unable to rip Avatar (US Region) with MakeMKV 1.5.4.

This is the error I received, (I did make sure I had the latest svq combo file listed at http://www.makemkv.com/svq/)

I have also attached the complete BD+ Dump file as well.

MakeMKV v1.5.4 beta darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/50CalAL/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL MATSHITA DVD-R UJ-857E ZA0E" opened in OS access mode.
Optical drive "BD-RE HL-DT-ST BD-RE WH08LS20 1.00" opened in OS access mode.
Using direct disc access mode
Loaded 1 SVQ file(s)
Processing BD+ code, please be patient - this may take up to few minutes
Processing BD+ code using generic SVQ from allcombo.svq
DEBUG: Code 0 at MoS=>=$b9ZW;a:gP:213133457
DEBUG: Code 0 at MoS=>=$b9ZW;a:gP:121263061
DEBUG: Code 0 at MoS=>=$b9ZW;a:gP:29398415
Failed to process BD+ code using generic SVQ from allcombo.svq
DEBUG: Code 0 at H5V8A/TY+@r"=9[0j=A&R:213133250
Saved BD+ dump file as /Users/50CalAL/Documents/BD Dumps/dump_Avatar_6C3EBCFBEA0D7827.tgz
Failed to process BD+ code, please check http://www.makemkv.com/svq/ for updated program and SVQ files
DEBUG: Code 0 at 68WhPFPEld[i/3(BiR{:213133296
Failed to open disc

[setarip_old]

Hi!

It doesn't hurt to report it again (I believe it's alkready been reported twice - one U.S. the other Europe), but it really doesn't provide any additional information.

As I posted in other threads (yesterday and today):

In another thread about "AVATAR" yesterday, I said:"I'm confident that shortly after the official U.S. release date of 4/22/10, MakeMKV will provide the means for dealing with the anticipated "Avatar" BluRay new BD+ protection. (MakeMKV is already capable of dealing withthe new v.17 of the AACS "key").the best of my knowledge, the new BD+ protection used with the "Avatar" BluRay has not yet been successfully circumvented by any program at this moment...

I just noticed that, just like "Crazy Heart", "Avatar" uses BMKV 16, not BMKV 17...

BTW - For future reference, there's no need to post your SVQ dumps to the forum. As the instructions indicate, Just send them to: svq@makemkv.com

[ragboy]

Same issue here, with US Avatar.

[vinger]

Hi, same issue here with the French release of Avatar blu-ray. Problem with the new BD+ protection system

[setarip_old]

Patience is a virtue ;>}

[50CalAL]

Thanks setarip_old

Totally forgot to send to svq@ for the BD+ Dump.

BTW - For future reference, there's no need to post your SVQ dumps to the forum. As the instructions indicate, Just send them to: svq@makemkv.com

[dtblair]

Same problem here, but boy does the movie look great on my OPPO

[Lcheng287]

Same problem here 50calAL

[ninety-nine_degrees]

My copy of MakeMKV 1.5.4 is making an MKV of Avatar blu-ray right now.

Download the free copy of DVDFab HD Decrypter from dvdfab.com.
Use the Blu-ray to Blu-ray function to copy the main movie to your hard drive.
Open the index.bdmv file in MakeMKV, chose your audio options, and away your go.

I'm sure the good folks here at MakeMKV will get it working with the new BD+ on Avatar shortly, but this is a good alternative in the meanwhile.

[xxxerxxxes]

Unfortunately my free copy of DVDFab HD Decrypter from dvdfab.com has expired. Since I refure the astronomical annual rates charged for that software I will wait. Thanks for the tip though, I;m sure many will benefit.

[ninety-nine_degrees]

Well, if you haven't used a 30 day trial from AnyDVD HD, they've cracked the BD+ as well.

[Harri]

Just to note: The German version of Avatar can't be ripped, either.

[starcrawler]

hi there,

you guys did incredible work with makemkv - it is a really fast native application for bluray-ripping: and these are rare on mac os x.
-gratulations!!!!

but what about your statement in the faqs:

"MakeMKV supports all commercial Blu-ray discs protected by latest versions of AACS and BD+. Occasionally, when movie studios update AACS and BD+ versions, a new version of MakeMKV needs to be downloaded. For the entire history of MakeMKV, the program was always updated next day after or days before the release date of disc employing new protection."

for mac users (without e.g. anydvd) it is still impossible to rip succesfully: neither days before the avatar-release nor now (more than several days after the release).


is there any problem regarding the bd+5 copyprotection?


best wishes!


starcrawler

[starcrawler]

sooooory!!!

just found the http://www.makemkv.com/forum2/viewtopic ... 1288#p4864 post!!!


b.t.w. already submitted my dump-file for the german-avatar-bluray on saturday....

[crowfax]

is there any problem regarding the bd+5 copyprotection?

I wouldn't call it a problem it's simply the case that programming takes time. He's working on it. If you want to help read this post and send him the information he needs:
http://www.makemkv.com/forum2/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=1288