all subtitles are the same language

[Sabine]

Hi,

just stumbled over a dvd where ripping produces 7x the same subtitle. The subtitle ripped is the first on the disc and it's then inserted for the other 6 languages, too.

I tested SubRip on the subs and this tool does a perfect job on them so it has to be a problem of MakeMKV, I suppose.


Sabine

[mike admin]

Hi Sabine,

It's very strange, we really shocked to hear that. Could you please send ifo files from that disc to mike.chen82@googlemail.com? Thank you!

[Sabine]

Mike,

just sent them to you.


Sabine

[mike admin]

Sabine,

Thank you, we'll check this out!

[mike admin]

Latest version 1.3 should pul language information correctly.

[Maritis]

I use v1.3 and have the same problem.
If i choose only one subtitle it's allways the first one :/

Any ideas?

[Shaq2k]

I have exactly the same problem.
I'm ripping from a .iso file with Virtual Clonedrive, and it is always the first subtitle that is actually ripped.

[mike admin]

We'll try to investigate. We haven't seen this error before.

[Shaq2k]

This issue seems to be resolved from v1.4.0.
Will do some more testing.

Thanks.

[mkv420]

This problem still exists in 1.4.1 beta for all the futurama disks

[mike admin]

This problem still exists in 1.4.1 beta for all the futurama disks

Can you please share ifo files for the disc that has this problem? Just copy all IFO files from the disc, compress with any archiver and either attach here or PM.

[mkv420]

IFOs attached. This also happens to be the same disk that MakeMKV fails to extract 4 of the 5 episodes on it (as referenced at http://www.makemkv.com/forum2/viewtopic.php?t=189)

[mike admin]

This is corrected in 1.4.2

[mkv420]

The first episode on the disk appears to have been extracted correctly, with all the subtitles (in 1.4.1 it only extracted english subtitles). However, the remaining 4 episodes only extract the intro sequence for the episode producing mkvs about 30K each and 30 seconds long (the first episode is about 1.1G and 22 minutes).

Code: Select all

FAILURE: Code 4294967276 at 'taY/:FM8E'M[0N%^~:29394068
FAILURE: Code 4294967276 at 'taY/:FM8E'M[0N%^~:29394068
FAILURE: Code 4294967276 at 'taY/:FM8E'M[0N%^~:29394068
FAILURE: Code 4294967276 at 'taY/:FM8E'M[0N%^~:29394068
FAILURE: Code 4294967276 at 'taY/:FM8E'M[0N%^~:29394068
FAILURE: Code 4294967276 at 'taY/:FM8E'M[0N%^~:121262601
FAILURE: Code 4294967276 at 'taY/:FM8E'M[0N%^~:29394597
Using direct disc access mode
Cell 8 was discarded (structure protection?)
Title #0 was added (7 cell(s), 0:22:27)
Cell 8 was discarded (structure protection?)
Title #1 was added (7 cell(s), 0:22:29)
Cell 7 was discarded (structure protection?)
Title #2 was added (6 cell(s), 0:22:30)
Cell 7 was discarded (structure protection?)
Title #3 was added (6 cell(s), 0:22:31)
Cell 8 was discarded (structure protection?)
Title #4 was added (7 cell(s), 0:22:27)
Title #5 with special attributes was skipped
Title #6 with special attributes was skipped
Title #7 with special attributes was skipped
Title #8 with special attributes was skipped
Title #9 has length of 0 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
Title #10 with special attributes was skipped
Operation sucessfully completed
Saving 5 titles into directory X:/Video/FUTURAMA_S2D3
5 titles saved

[mkv420]

I should mention that the results are the same if MakeMKV is pointed directly at the disk or at the DVDFAB5HD extracted directory.