Oppenheimer (2023)

[ShoutingMan]

Thanks. I tried again cleaning carefully and it’s still failing around the 33% mark. Both in MakeMKV and AnyDVD. So I’m returning it. Hopefully replacement disc will work.

I got my copy from Amazon as well. Also disc errors about 3/4 in, cleaning and 2 different drives not withstanding. Requested a replacement, they project replacement delivery on January 11 (!). Sux.
-Alan

Bummer. It's not clear if it's a bad disc or a problem reading Amazon discs by the current software. My experience is this is more likely an issue with MakeMKV and AnyDVD at early release, as the disc had not obvious substantial flaws. But it could be the disc and so I'll replace it and see if that fixes the problem.

[18Loco]

3CB4 corresponds to the disc ID 0x8C887E9C572BA6B2A2FCFF32EC38A33E81D7D24D, the unit key for which is in the online VUK database and was posted at viewtopic.php?p=143661#p143661. I managed to play my 3CB4 disc in VLC (with libaacs installed and the key in my KEYDB.cfg file) and rip it with ffmpeg (it manages to select the right title automatically, change /dev/sr1 to your drive device):

Code: Select all

ffmpeg -i bluray:/dev/sr1 -c copy -map 0 Oppenheimer.mkv

(This only works after attempting to open the disc in MakeMKV to enable LibreDrive mode.)

MakeMKV can't decrypt it, even with the KEYDB.cfg file containing the key in my .MakeMKV directory, presumably because MakeMKV requires the VUK and the key database only contains a unit key.

Is there a tutorial for how to use ffmpeg to rip a disc anywhere? Trying to do this and I'm lost

[miclo]

3CB4 corresponds to the disc ID 0x8C887E9C572BA6B2A2FCFF32EC38A33E81D7D24D, the unit key for which is in the online VUK database and was posted at viewtopic.php?p=143661#p143661. I managed to play my 3CB4 disc in VLC (with libaacs installed and the key in my KEYDB.cfg file) and rip it with ffmpeg (it manages to select the right title automatically, change /dev/sr1 to your drive device):

Code: Select all

ffmpeg -i bluray:/dev/sr1 -c copy -map 0 Oppenheimer.mkv

(This only works after attempting to open the disc in MakeMKV to enable LibreDrive mode.)

MakeMKV can't decrypt it, even with the KEYDB.cfg file containing the key in my .MakeMKV directory, presumably because MakeMKV requires the VUK and the key database only contains a unit key.

The FFMPEG command worked great for me, even using Windows (after installing libaacs and updating KEYDB.cfg). Thanks!

I'm really wondering why it is taking so long to add this disc to MakeMKV - is this normal for 4k Blu-Rays?

[deltaexray]

Tried it this morning, 3CB4 stil does not work. That's a bummer tbh but we'll see when it will work.
- Alex

[bay73]

Hello,

UK user and have successfully ripped 100+ UHD's with makeMKV but have hit a brick wall with my Amazon sourced Oppenheimer disk.

Not sure if there is anything I can do? I'm not techie at all so not sure what info I can post here to get some advice? But this is the error message I get:

Using LibreDrive mode (v06.3 id=866A98CB9C4E)
Using direct disc access mode
Loaded content hash table, will verify integrity of M2TS files.
Saved AACS dump file as C:\Users\User/.MakeMKV/MKB20_v77_Oppenheimer_3CB4.tgz
The volume key is unknown for this disc - video can't be decrypted
Failed to open disc

Any help would be appreciated. Thanks

[maynestopia]

I had to submit my .tgz code to svq@makemkv.com as its a bit different to the other codes i've seen on this forum.

MKB20_v77_Oppenheimer_8B8A.tgz

[Boogie2005]

Here is my dump file. UHD disc arrived today, unfortunately it doesn't work either.

[H3cxDev]

Just tried again with 3CB4, still no luck for those wondering.

[irving9901]

3CB4 corresponds to the disc ID 0x8C887E9C572BA6B2A2FCFF32EC38A33E81D7D24D, the unit key for which is in the online VUK database and was posted at viewtopic.php?p=143661#p143661. I managed to play my 3CB4 disc in VLC (with libaacs installed and the key in my KEYDB.cfg file) and rip it with ffmpeg (it manages to select the right title automatically, change /dev/sr1 to your drive device):

Code: Select all

ffmpeg -i bluray:/dev/sr1 -c copy -map 0 Oppenheimer.mkv

(This only works after attempting to open the disc in MakeMKV to enable LibreDrive mode.)

MakeMKV can't decrypt it, even with the KEYDB.cfg file containing the key in my .MakeMKV directory, presumably because MakeMKV requires the VUK and the key database only contains a unit key.

Is there a tutorial for how to use ffmpeg to rip a disc anywhere? Trying to do this and I'm lost

I was able to play the 3CB4 via VLC as arthomnix described. But I do not understand how to rip with ffmpeg. How to find out the name of my drive device (Libre Drive: ASUS USB-Device) in the /dev-String? Is there a connection between VLC and ffmpeg?

[mw2002]

Just tried again with 3CB4, still no luck for those wondering.

[deltaexray]

Can confirm, 3CB4 stil does not work. By now, I'm wondering If it will work at all
- Alex

[H3cxDev]

Can confirm, 3CB4 stil does not work. By now, I'm wondering If it will work at all
- Alex

I would hope it works as I have ripped AACS2.0/v77 disks before, it might just be harder to get those famous keys that they need, hopefully it shouldn’t take too much longer but it would be good to hear from someone at MakeMKV as to why it’s taking unusually long.

[arthomnix]

3CB4 corresponds to the disc ID 0x8C887E9C572BA6B2A2FCFF32EC38A33E81D7D24D, the unit key for which is in the online VUK database and was posted at viewtopic.php?p=143661#p143661. I managed to play my 3CB4 disc in VLC (with libaacs installed and the key in my KEYDB.cfg file) and rip it with ffmpeg (it manages to select the right title automatically, change /dev/sr1 to your drive device):

Code: Select all

ffmpeg -i bluray:/dev/sr1 -c copy -map 0 Oppenheimer.mkv

(This only works after attempting to open the disc in MakeMKV to enable LibreDrive mode.)

MakeMKV can't decrypt it, even with the KEYDB.cfg file containing the key in my .MakeMKV directory, presumably because MakeMKV requires the VUK and the key database only contains a unit key.

Is there a tutorial for how to use ffmpeg to rip a disc anywhere? Trying to do this and I'm lost

I was able to play the 3CB4 via VLC as arthomnix described. But I do not understand how to rip with ffmpeg. How to find out the name of my drive device (Libre Drive: ASUS USB-Device) in the /dev-String? Is there a connection between VLC and ffmpeg?

/dev/srX is only used by Linux, on Windows I assume it would be the drive letter of your drive (e.g. bluray:D:\)
It should be the same as the "disc device" you selected in VLC's Media > Open Disc dialog

[deltaexray]

Can confirm, 3CB4 stil does not work. By now, I'm wondering If it will work at all
- Alex

I would hope it works as I have ripped AACS2.0/v77 disks before, it might just be harder to get those famous keys that they need, hopefully it shouldn’t take too much longer but it would be good to hear from someone at MakeMKV as to why it’s taking unusually long.

A response from them would be really nice, yes. Wait and see sunshine, eh?

[hunk.]

I was able to play the 3CB4 via VLC as arthomnix described. But I do not understand how to rip with ffmpeg. How to find out the name of my drive device (Libre Drive: ASUS USB-Device) in the /dev-String? Is there a connection between VLC and ffmpeg?

To get ffmpeg to work on Windows, you need the following folder structure:

ffmpeg folder:
ffmpeg.exe
libaacs.dll
libbdplus.dll
libbluray-awt-j2se-1.3.4.jar
libbluray-j2se-1.3.4.jar
libgcrypt-20.dll
libgpg-error6-0.dll

%ProgramData%\aacs:
keydb.cfg

Then you run (if your bluray drive is D:) :
ffmpeg -i "bluray:D:" -c copy -map 0 Oppenheimer.mkv