Right it's artificing from misalignment - I saw the same thing when trying to encode 'Transformers (2007)' base layer and add full FEL layer back in before we realized encoding BL on FEL titles does this (misaligns slightly and creates random flashing artifacts at times) and you just have to remux them instead (without pro tools to re-encode I suppose) - that's what I made my own old FEL test file fromRESET_9999 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 05, 2022 8:38 pmright but those flashes are just a buggy reaction, not the actual RPU working.
I prefer quietvoid's rpu test file + power rangers sample for fel
Because when you play the clockwork file on a player that is not supposed to have an RPU reaction like MPV, there's still a rpu reaction because the file is actually buggy and not because the rpu is working.
If you play quietvoid's rpu test file on MPV, there is no reaction at all which is the correct behavior.
But it only shows the artifacts if trying to display the RPU - because it is RPU playback capable - is what I'm getting at, and the impression I was under - which would mean it still works as a test if so, right? I've never had it flash colors on a non-capable device.
MPV doesn't show color artifacts for me it stays red/orange until the BL changes itself. How were you able to get the flashing to show?
Edit: I do have the queitvoid test as well, and run through all of them on a device (the p7/p8/p5 test files)
Double edit: I can get the flashing to show in MPV, but just like Windows Store apps with Dolby Vision plugin - it IS supposed to show RPU this way - even if not 100% PQ accurate on playback if that's what you meant, because I know you don't like Windows Store apps for DV playback because of PQ/color inaccuracy - so just like the SHIELD, even though MPV can't show FEL video data, it uses RPU effects from FEL layer still to display some DV effects - so same effects output as if MEL (again, even if not 100% PQ accuracy)
Code: Select all
mpv.com --target-trc=pq --target-prim=bt.2020 --vo=gpu-next --gpu-context=d3d11 file.mp4/mkv/ts
If you try to play without that command, it displays NO RPU effects/artifacts at all - as I would expect
So it does seem the flashing colors will only show when RPU is supposed to be displayed, which is how I always thought
Edit:
I missed this part - but I still don't understand - how can it show artifacts from RPU if not processing RPU (even if inaccurately) ? Queitvoid's doesn't work like you said, but the Profile 5 misaligned file does work as intended too. Is it that it doesn't adhere to standards or certain formats/levels of authored RPU(CMV 4.0 or whatever it's called) ? - but it is still showing RPU (in all but queitvoid's test) when trying to, on purpose - and this only effects MPV curiously - I've never had a device work with the FEL test that didn't work with queitvoid's test - MPV now asideRESET_9999 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 05, 2022 8:38 pmIf you play quietvoid's rpu test file on MPV, there is no reaction at all which is the correct behavior.