Nine Bluray shows up as "No Disc"

[brainscan276]

I use makemkv to save Bluray discs as iso-files. I have several drives that work fine with a lot of discs even UHD Blurays.

I own two copies of the german edition of Nine as well as a UK edition. All Bluray discs of this movie don't seem to work with makemkv (or is it Windows?). After starting makemkv and inserting the disc, makemkv shows the animation that it reads the disc. But after some time the process ends with the indication "No disc" like described in this reddit thread. I tried all of my drives (4 of them internal ASUS BW-16D1HT, ASUS BC-12D2HT, LG BH16NS55, Pioneer BDR-S12U, 1 via USB LG BU40N) as well as the different discs. All combinations with the same result: "No disc". The windows explorer is also not showing the discs after inserting it.

But using one of the discs in my Xbox One is no problem: it is recognoized and the Bluray player starts to play it without any hassle. So the discs are ok. Has someone an idea what is wrong with reading these discs in a PC drive?

[Coopervid]

I use makemkv to save Bluray discs as iso-files. I have several drives that work fine with a lot of discs even UHD Blurays.

I own two copies of the german edition of Nine as well as a UK edition. All Bluray discs of this movie don't seem to work with makemkv (or is it Windows?). After starting makemkv and inserting the disc, makemkv shows the animation that it reads the disc. But after some time the process ends with the indication "No disc" like described in this reddit thread. I tried all of my drives (4 of them internal ASUS BW-16D1HT, ASUS BC-12D2HT, LG BH16NS55, Pioneer BDR-S12U, 1 via USB LG BU40N) as well as the different discs. All combinations with the same result: "No disc". The windows explorer is also not showing the discs after inserting it.

But using one of the discs in my Xbox One is no problem: it is recognoized and the Bluray player starts to play it without any hassle. So the discs are ok. Has someone an idea what is wrong with reading these discs in a PC drive?

Wash the discs with liquid soap.