I accept this might not necessarily be a MakeMKV issue, but if anyone is likely to know they'll be on this forum
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e34c3/e34c32c611d6db29bd541897014be8ca616ef7bd" alt="Very Happy :D"
I've had 2 copies now of Deception on Blu Ray and both fail to even read (on either PC with the same drive type) i.e. the PC just doesn't recognise the disc. It's the only disc I've ever seen this problem on, but it would appear to be inherant. No error messages in MakeMKV, it just fails to recognise the disc (after a lot of churning and grunting).
It's a UK version, loading on an ASUS BW-16D1HT - anyone out there ever experienced such a problem?
Or any advice on how to troubleshoot this sort of thing?