BBC planet earth, 2/4 titles failed

[drewg]

When attempting to save disc1 of BBC's planet earth, 2 of the 4 titles fail to save. Both behave exactly the same -- the rip proceeds normally until the title is 99.9% done, then it says there was an exception, and it failed to save the title. I have not yet tried the other 3 discs in this set.

Here is the debug log from attempting to save one of the failing titles:

Code: Select all

Debug log started at Tue Aug 17 15:10:34 2010 , written by MakeMKV v1.5.8 linux(x64-release)
Using 524544KB for read cache.
001005:0000 MakeMKV v1.5.8 linux(x64-release) started
001004:0000 Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /home/gallatin/MakeMKV_log.txt
003007:0000 Using direct disc access mode
005050:0000 Evaluation version, 12 day(s) out of 30 remaining
DISCID=54B89048B860B79B7C83687643E9AF78894708F1
003307:0000 File 00005.mpls was added as title #0
003307:0000 File 00024.mpls was added as title #1
003307:0000 File 00025.mpls was added as title #2
003307:0000 File 00026.mpls was added as title #3
003307:0000 File 00020.mpls was added as title #4
003309:0000 Title 00021.mpls is equal to title 00024.mpls and was skipped
003309:0000 Title 00022.mpls is equal to title 00025.mpls and was skipped
003309:0000 Title 00023.mpls is equal to title 00026.mpls and was skipped
003025:0000 Title #00014.m2ts has length of 29 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
003025:0000 Title #00018.m2ts has length of 11 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
003025:0000 Title #00019.m2ts has length of 21 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
003025:0000 Title #00020.m2ts has length of 11 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
005011:0000 Operation sucessfully completed
005014:0000 Saving 1 titles into directory /video/tmp
tp=PxuKImokMlnRhg9vDA4DUDlG0ygo2ozW5i6tPGduwvCQdgvvhAK58AHDudArTsusdWnkE++WKfpTbx72XJrZhfykBfp7AqR4nJ5fuqrP6FHfRMEel6zxHDbOU5hD6RkQlsrBzBZLFLk+jwjIfBeAER55HAiDFiYJTBj/JmqJJEQB2YA9Q9IDv+niYA7GaUuY6ZOcPEzSbHS0Rw9jRLSjmhnRE+iRsspNbShuDVSANjYRL+Rsvwye4FIhfoBo=
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at q[/d$[(SR<W2)Dc'2se0:213130973
tp=Pcpzsc8biiJqJDJZ0YYPbwwOA1A5RtMoKNqM1uYurTxnbsLwkHYL74QCufABw7nQK07LrHVp5BPvlin6U28e9lya2YX8pAX6ewKkeJyeX7qqz+hR30TBHpes8Rw2zlOYQ+kZEJbKwcwWSxS5Po8IyHwXgBEeeRwIgxYmCUwY/yZqiSREAdmAPUPSA7/p4mAOxmlLmOmTnDxM0mx0tEcPY0S0o5oZ0RPokbLKTW0obg1UgDY2ES/kbL8MnuBSIX6Aa
ts0=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
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at m^JjQ9\DPKFt)u^"v9F5:213130513
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 3737712 at m^JjQ9\DPKFt)u^"v9F5:213129639
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at J$3.?>' K+JEQU3}iWe4V:29397449
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at J$3.?>' K+JEQU3}iWe4V:29397449
001002:0020 LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
005003:0000 Failed to save title 3 to file /video/tmp/title03.mkv
005004:0080 0 titles saved, 1 failed
005037:0204 Copy complete. 0 titles saved, 1 failed.

This is a brand-new just out of the shrinkwrap BD. I will try the other discs now..

Thanks,

Drew

[setarip_old]

Hi!

Have you played the originals to see if the same problem exists?

[drewg]

Hi!
Have you played the originals to see if the same problem exists?

My only BD player is the one I'm ripping from.

The goal is to RIP BDs I purchase onto my SageTV media server, and watch them via my SageTV media extenders. Last night, I realized that SageTV understands BD structure, so I used the backup menu option to rip the disc. This time, the rip completed w/o error. I only had time to watch 1 of the 3 episodes, so I'm not sure yet if it really works..

FWIW, some of the other discs had the same issue when attempting to make MKVs.

Drew

[mike admin]

A corrupt m2ts file, the next version of MakeMKV will have a workaround. For now you can make decrypted backup and play m2ts files.

[drewg]

A corrupt m2ts file, the next version of MakeMKV will have a workaround. For now you can make decrypted backup and play m2ts files.

The decrypted backup worked fine, and had a very minor glitch near the end of the video (at roughly where the title copy failed). Question: Is the corrupt m2ts due to a bad mastering process, a scratched BD, bad BD drive / firmware, or something else?

Thanks,

Drew

[setarip_old]

Is the corrupt m2ts due to a bad mastering process, a scratched BD...

Those are the two most likely reasons.

I'd suggest you return the disc(s) to the place of purchase in exchange for new replacement(s)...