HD-DVD Rip Problems

[dellsam34]

Trying to rip my HD-DVD collection to HDD and I'm facing problems with a lot of discs, I thought it was the dreaded disc rot but I'm not entirely sure, My drive is HL-DT-ST BD-RE GGW-H20L YL05 (USB3 plugged) on a Windows 11 64bit using makemkv rip app, The problematic discs do not list the main feature just the bonus features, here is a copy of the log of one of the bad discs:

Code: Select all

Title #PARALOGO.EVO has length of 14 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
Title #BLACK.EVO has length of 60 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
Title #MENUINTRO.EVO has length of 48 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
Title #MENULOOP.EVO has length of 42 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
Title #DELETED.EVO has length of 106 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 120 seconds and was therefore skipped
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 14336-18432, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 24576, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 24576, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 24576-26624, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 26624, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 26624, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 30720, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 30720-32768, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 32768-34816, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 34816-36864, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 36864, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 43008, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 43008-45056, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 45056-47104, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 47104-49152, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 53248, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 53248-55296, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 55296-57344, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 57344-59392, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 59392-61440, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 61440, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 67584, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 67584-69632, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 69632-71680, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 71680-75776, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 75776-77824, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 77824, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 83968, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 83968-86016, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 86016, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 90112, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 90112-92160, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 92160-94208, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 94208-98304, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 98304-100352, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 100352-102400, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 102400, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 108544, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 108544-110592, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 110592, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 110592, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 14336-16384, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 22528, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 40960, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 40960, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 65536, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 65536, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 81920, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 81920, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 106496, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 106496, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 133120, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/FEATURE_1.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 133120, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 10240, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 14336-16384, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 16384, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480-22528, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 22528-24576, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 24576-26624, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 38912, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 38912, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 43008, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 43008-45056, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 45056, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 49152, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 49152-51200, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 51200-53248, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 53248-57344, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 57344, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 57344, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 90112, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 106496, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 137216, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 137216, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 167936, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 167936, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 215040, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 215040, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 251904, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 251904, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 309248, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 309248, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 368640-370688, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 370688, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 370688, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 417792, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 417792, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 444416, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 444416, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 444416, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 495616, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 495616, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 546816, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 546816, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 546816, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 608256, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 608256, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 673792-675840, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 675840, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 737280, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 737280, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 747520, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 747520, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 784384, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 784384, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 837632, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 837632, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 882688, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 882688, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/TRADE.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 937984, attempting to work around

......... removed to meet forum character max number......

The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 12288, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
The source file '/HVDVD_TS/ALT_DLS.EVO' is corrupt or invalid at offset 20480, attempting to work around
Operation successfully completed

[dcoke22]

The optical drive is clearly struggling to read some spots on that disc. The only advice I can offer is to gently clean the disc and try again.

[dellsam34]

The disc is very clean, no obvious scratches or dirt.

[b00ga]

As I've recently come to find out, apparently HD-DVD is just a format that doesn't survive the test of time. I've recently started creating a digital archive of all my movies/shows and building a Jellyfin server. Out of about a dozen HD-DVDs, only 2 have successfully ripped. I have two different drives (an X-Box HD-DVD and a Toshiba slim laptop drive).

From everything I'm reading on various forums (eg AVSForum or VideoHelp), the HD-DVDs degrade in numerous different ways and become unreadable, no matter how clean they look to the human eye.

AFAIK, everything that came out on HD-DVD has been re-released on Blu-Ray and I've started replacing my discs.

[Deeply_Cynical]

AFAIK, everything that came out on HD-DVD has been re-released on Blu-Ray and I've started replacing my discs.

Not Everything, It's still the ONLY way to get a HD physical copy of The Dukes of Hazzard (2005). Some may consider that a blessing.

Getting back to the OP's question, I've had issues decrypting discs with an AAC revision of >1 with makeMKV.

To get around this I've used DumpHD to decrypt and dump the entire disc contents, then, in makeMKV open the "HVA00001.VTI" file from the decrypted HVDVD_TS folder. You can then use MakeMKV to demux as normal.
I then use a combination of eac3to and mkvtoolnix to process the soft telecine flags and restore the 24fps framerate.