www.makemkv.com

I upgraded to MakeMKV 1.6.7 for Linux.

I had noticed some hiccups in video/audio playback of Tangled using 1.6.5, so I tried to re-copy using 1.6.7, but there are still hiccups. So, no luck there. Attached is the log.

Additionally, two other DVD that failed to copy under 1.6.5 (Final Destination 3 and P.S. I Love You) still fail to copy under 1.6.7.

Still hoping these issues will eventually get sorted out.

Error messages in your log do indicate an error but they only would lead to slower copy speeds, not a corrupted file. You should have gotten a valid MKV file in the end. Did you submit logs for discs that fail earlier?

mike admin wrote:Error messages in your log do indicate an error but they only would lead to slower copy speeds, not a corrupted file. You should have gotten a valid MKV file in the end.

Strange, but I am definitely seeing a hiccup at the same place during repeated playback attempts.

mike admin wrote:Did you submit logs for discs that fail earlier?

No, I didn't, but I will do so. Actually, P.S. I Love You just hangs and never exits, so I might not be able to get the log for that one...I'll see if it outputs anything in its file.

I am getting errors on Tangled blu-ray too. ELEVEN HOURS into just the PRE-RIP analysis and it's only HALF WAY DONE with that! It is absurd to take 24hrs just to analyze a disc for eventual ripping, no? Something is seriously hosed. I have no idea what a DASPI kernel is, or if that would actually help here. Anyone?

<rip log deleted because the gorram system says 60k characters is too many> WTF?! I'm trying to help here.... if you want to see the log, give me a window into which I can paste it!

PS: so I clicked the X (stop this crazy thing!) button, and was presented with the Rip-Me list. HUH?? Well, I guess we'll see what happens next.

Waste of time is what happens:


Operation successfully completed
Saving 10 titles into directory /Tangled
DEBUG: Code 0 at 07-R1mcAGYg^gR'B;:121264211
Error 'Posix error - Input/output error' occurred while reading '/BDMV/STREAM/00123.m2ts' at offset '13762560'
Error 'Posix error - Input/output error' occurred while reading '/BDMV/STREAM/00123.m2ts' at offset '13762560'
DEBUG: Code 0 at CH0\Z/As%]{q?(}+hdsU:29394298
DEBUG: Code 0 at 7~L~3<ng+6"(X@ySMiZ#:121261681
DEBUG: Code 0 at CH0\Z/As%]{q?(}+hdsU:29394183
DEBUG: Code 6720 at CH0\Z/As%]{q?(}+hdsU:29393309
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4\0=4Z*yD&9{!<07Ww*af:29397472
DEBUG: Code 0 at :BtS@cD"Q/uf'Q`wL@*:121263751
DEBUG: Code 0 at :BtS@cD"Q/uf'Q`wL@*:121265108
DEBUG: Code 0 at :BtS@cD"Q/uf'Q`wL@*:213130444
DEBUG: Code 0 at :BtS@cD"Q/uf'Q`wL@*:121261934
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4\0=4Z*yD&9{!<07Ww*af:29397587
DEBUG: Code 0 at -%a[)Iw>Rs_6^1NSqXo:29394160
DEBUG: Code 0 at -%a[)Iw>Rs_6^1NSqXo:121263843
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 0 to file /Tangled/title00.mkv
DEBUG: Code 0 at 07-R1mcAGYg^gR'B;:121264211
Error 'Posix error - Input/output error' occurred while reading '/BDMV/STREAM/00124.m2ts' at offset '122880'
Error 'Posix error - Input/output error' occurred while reading '/BDMV/STREAM/00124.m2ts' at offset '122880'
DEBUG: Code 0 at CH0\Z/As%]{q?(}+hdsU:29394298
DEBUG: Code 0 at 7~L~3<ng+6"(X@ySMiZ#:121261681
DEBUG: Code 0 at CH0\Z/As%]{q?(}+hdsU:29394183
DEBUG: Code 60 at CH0\Z/As%]{q?(}+hdsU:29393309
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4\0=4Z*yD&9{!<07Ww*af:29397587
DEBUG: Code 0 at _o,#|P@]<XYj@eO V])i:121268765
DEBUG: Code 0 at _o,#|P@]<XYj@eO V])i:29400692
DEBUG: Code 0 at 4\0=4Z*yD&9{!<07Ww*af:29397587
DEBUG: Code 0 at -%a[)Iw>Rs_6^1NSqXo:29394160
DEBUG: Code 0 at -%a[)Iw>Rs_6^1NSqXo:121263843
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 1 to file /Tangled/title01.mkv


EDIT: Yet ANOTHER case of IT Crowd "turn it off and on again". Geez! What is the deal here? I powercycle the blu-ray drive, restart MakeMKV and suddenly the rip proceeds with alacrity. sigh. IMHO, MakeMKV should at the very least offer this as a solution any time it's initial scan takes more than a minute or two.

Aside: The skipping of all tracks less than two minutes could be a huge problem on certain discs. On an animation compilation this would skip almost ALL of the awesome hand-made shorts! Any solutions to this? (Yes, I have seen the Prefs/Video/Min title length option, but it refuses to let me set it to less than 120 seconds!)

@captain

1) You post does not seem to be related to this thread

2)

(Yes, I have seen the Prefs/Video/Min title length option, but it refuses to let me set it to less than 120 seconds!)

Naah - you should (as I have) be able to set it to as low as 2 seconds...

captain wrote: Error 'Posix error - Input/output error' occurred while reading '/BDMV/STREAM/00123.m2ts' at offset '13762560'

It seems that you have a physically damaged disc.

mike admin wrote:Did you submit logs for discs that fail earlier?

I've attached the logs for the two other discs that failed. I had to compress the one log since it was huge and would have been bigger had I not killed it. Thanks.

heavy wrote:

mike admin wrote:Did you submit logs for discs that fail earlier?

I've attached the logs for the two other discs that failed. I had to compress the one log since it was huge and would have been bigger had I not killed it. Thanks.

For both disc please copy all IFO and BUP files, also run and save the output. Compress IFO files with corresponding makemkvcon output and send to support@makemkv.com . At a first glance it looks like both failures are caused by errors in MakeMKV.

mike admin wrote: For both disc please copy all IFO and BUP files, also run

Code: Select all

makemkvcon --debug -r info disc:0

and save the output. Compress IFO files with corresponding makemkvcon output and send to support@makemkv.com . At a first glance it looks like both failures are caused by errors in MakeMKV.

I sent the requested info for both discs. Thanks.

FYI. I'm not sure if 1.6.10 was supposed to address the issues in the movies for which I submitted information (i.e., P.S. ILove You and Final Destination 3), but I tried to copy them again and they still fail.

Just another update after upgrading to 1.6.12...both discs still fail to copy.