Page 1 of 1

very low audio output on ripped dvd to MKV

Posted: Sun Jan 13, 2013 8:16 am
by guymad
I have a Antec Fusion X2 Media Centre PC running Window 7 64Bit and windows media centre soft ware.
My question is I ripped all my dvd's using "MakeMKV" software and down loaded the codex required to run MKV on windows media centre and get a great picture but the sound is really very low about 10% of where it should be- checked the sound mixer on the pc and not a problem,played a dvd which was ripped AVI and perfect, Tried playing music via itunes and works perfectly so not a hardware issue so leads me to think it is either:
- The ripping process to MKV - but do not think so as there is no area in their software to modify sound o/p level.
- Codex issues

Ideas please???

Re: very low audio output on ripped dvd to MKV

Posted: Sun Jan 13, 2013 5:54 pm
by leenuss
Most likely, your MKV contains the original surround sound audio. Multichannel sound files with lots of headroom. Windows Media Player will perform a stereo mixdown but attenuates the volume level to not risk distortion or clipping when 6+ channels of audio will saved to 2 channels.

Your DVD ripped to AVI probably didn't have multichannel surround audio. Either it used a stereo track on the DVD, or the AVI conversion process made a stereo mixdown, then normalized the audio levels to increase the volume.

Re: very low audio output on ripped dvd to MKV

Posted: Sun Jan 13, 2013 7:45 pm
by Romansh
leenuss wrote:Multichannel sound files with lots of headroom. Windows Media Player will perform a stereo mixdown but attenuates the volume level to not risk distortion or clipping when 6+ channels of audio will saved to 2 channels.
My experience is that multichannel audio on DVD and Blu-ray does not have that much headroom. But you are correct in that many devices will normalize Stereo downmix coefficients to avoid clipping, with the result being a low output volume.
leenuss wrote:Either it used a stereo track on the DVD, or the AVI conversion process made a stereo mixdown, then normalized the audio levels to increase the volume.
It would indeed seem likely.