DSAPI Mountain Lion LG BD-RE BH10LS30

[Affrae]

Hi - I get the following whenever I run MakeMKV - definitely happens in Mountain Lion, cannot remember if I got it in Lion, as it's been a while since I fired this up.

MakeMKV v1.7.71 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/daniel/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL HL-DT-ST DVDRW GA32N KE06" opened in DASPI v1.3 mode.
Optical drive "BD-RE HL-DT-ST BD-RE BH10LS30 1.01" opened in DASPI v1.3 mode.
Error 'Scsi error - ILLEGAL REQUEST:INVALID COMMAND OPERATION CODE' occurred while issuing SCSI command 46020..00140 to device 'DASPI:IODASPIService:c9e81734b1ab85e5:'
DEBUG: Code 0 at 0*D@[@0TV$@)^y@;:213137183
Optical drive "BD-ROM WD Virtual CD 1112 1012" opened in DASPI v1.3 mode.
Error 'Scsi error - ILLEGAL REQUEST:INVALID COMMAND OPERATION CODE' occurred while issuing SCSI command 46020..00140 to device 'DASPI:IODASPIService:c9e81734b1ab85e5:'
DEBUG: Code 0 at 0*D@[@0TV$@)^y@;:213137183
Using direct disc access mode

Is this expected behaviour? I am lucky to get 2x reads from my BD-RE BH10LS30. The only other thing I thought of is that the drive is connected via eSata to a LaCie Thunderbolt eSata hub - however, I am getting the same notifications from a USB 2.0 connection.

Thanks in advance for any suggestions anyone can provide.

Aff

[Romansh]

Works fine here (same OS, same drive):

Code: Select all

MakeMKV v1.7.71 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/tim/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL MATSHITA DVD-R UJ-8A8 HB14" opened in DASPI v1.3 mode.
Optical drive "BD-RE HL-DT-ST BD-RE BH10LS30 1.01" opened in DASPI v1.3 mode.
Using direct disc access mode
File 00287.mpls was added as title #0
File 00435.mpls was added as title #1
File 00436.mpls was added as title #2
File 00437.mpls was added as title #3
File 00438.mpls was added as title #4
File 00448.mpls was added as title #5
File 00450.mpls was added as title #6
File 00451.mpls was added as title #7
File 00452.mpls was added as title #8
File 00363.mpls was added as title #9
File 00365.mpls was added as title #10
File 00366.mpls was added as title #11
File 00379.mpls was added as title #12
File 00250.mpls was added as title #13
File 00250.mpls(2) was added as title #14
File 00250.mpls(4) was added as title #15
File 00250.mpls(6) was added as title #16
File 00250.mpls(8) was added as title #17
File 00250.mpls(10) was added as title #18
Title 00250.mpls(12) is equal to title 00287.mpls and was skipped
File 00020.mpls was added as title #19
File 00309.mpls was added as title #20
File 00324.mpls was added as title #21
File 00324.mpls(12) was added as title #22
File 00324.mpls(15) was added as title #23
Title 00325.mpls is equal to title 00324.mpls and was skipped
File 00331.mpls was added as title #24
File 00295.mpls(1) was added as title #25
File 00427.mpls(1) was added as title #26
Title 00427.mpls(2) is equal to title 00427.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00427.mpls(3) is equal to title 00427.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00430.mpls(1) was added as title #27
Title 00430.mpls(2) is equal to title 00430.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00430.mpls(3) is equal to title 00430.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00430.mpls(4) is equal to title 00430.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00430.mpls(5) was added as title #28
File 00431.mpls(1) was added as title #29
Title 00431.mpls(2) is equal to title 00431.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00431.mpls(3) is equal to title 00431.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00431.mpls(4) is equal to title 00431.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00431.mpls(5) is equal to title 00431.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00444.mpls(1) was added as title #30
Title 00444.mpls(2) is equal to title 00444.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00444.mpls(3) is equal to title 00444.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00445.mpls(1) was added as title #31
Title 00445.mpls(2) is equal to title 00445.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00445.mpls(3) is equal to title 00445.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00445.mpls(4) is equal to title 00445.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00446.mpls(1) was added as title #32
Title 00446.mpls(2) is equal to title 00446.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00446.mpls(3) is equal to title 00446.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00446.mpls(4) is equal to title 00446.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00446.mpls(5) is equal to title 00446.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00453.mpls(1) was added as title #33
Title 00453.mpls(2) is equal to title 00453.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00453.mpls(3) is equal to title 00453.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00453.mpls(4) is equal to title 00453.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00453.mpls(5) is equal to title 00453.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00453.mpls(6) is equal to title 00453.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00453.mpls(7) is equal to title 00453.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00453.mpls(8) is equal to title 00453.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00455.mpls(1) was added as title #34
Title 00455.mpls(2) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(3) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(4) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(5) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(6) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(7) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(8) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(9) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(10) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(11) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(12) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(13) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(14) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(15) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(16) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(17) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(18) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(19) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(20) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(21) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(22) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(23) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00455.mpls(24) is equal to title 00455.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00456.mpls(1) was added as title #35
Title 00456.mpls(2) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(3) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(4) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(5) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(6) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(7) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(8) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(9) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(10) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(11) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(12) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(13) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(14) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(15) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(16) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(17) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(18) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(19) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(20) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(21) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(22) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(23) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(24) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(25) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(26) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(27) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(28) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00456.mpls(29) is equal to title 00456.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00457.mpls(1) was added as title #36
Title 00457.mpls(2) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(3) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(4) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(5) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(6) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(7) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(8) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(9) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(10) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(11) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(12) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(13) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(14) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(15) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(16) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(17) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(18) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(19) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(20) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(21) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(22) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(23) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(24) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(25) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(26) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(27) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(28) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(29) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(30) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(31) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(32) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00457.mpls(33) is equal to title 00457.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00461.mpls(1) was added as title #37
Title 00461.mpls(2) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(3) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(4) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(5) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(6) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(7) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(8) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(9) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(10) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(11) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(12) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(13) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(14) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(15) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(16) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(17) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(18) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(19) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(20) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(21) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(22) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(23) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(24) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(25) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(26) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(27) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(28) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(29) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(30) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(31) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(32) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(33) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(34) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(35) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(36) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(37) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(38) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(39) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(40) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(41) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(42) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
Title 00461.mpls(43) is equal to title 00461.mpls(1) and was skipped
File 00478.mpls was added as title #38
File 00358.mpls was added as title #39
File 00391.mpls was added as title #40
File 00357.mpls was added as title #41
File 00251.mpls was added as title #42
File 00252.mpls was added as title #43
File 00273.mpls was added as title #44
File 00274.mpls was added as title #45
File 00275.mpls was added as title #46
File 00538.mpls was added as title #47
Title #00013.m2ts has length of 0 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 1 seconds and was therefore skipped
Title #00014.m2ts has length of 0 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 1 seconds and was therefore skipped
Title #00416.m2ts has length of 0 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 1 seconds and was therefore skipped
File 00445.m2ts was added as title #48
File 00446.m2ts was added as title #49
Title #00456.m2ts has length of 0 seconds which is less than minimum title length of 1 seconds and was therefore skipped
File 00466.m2ts was added as title #50
File 00468.m2ts was added as title #51
File 00469.m2ts was added as title #52
File 00470.m2ts was added as title #53
File 00471.m2ts was added as title #54
File 00472.m2ts was added as title #55
File 00478.m2ts was added as title #56
File 00479.m2ts was added as title #57
File 00481.m2ts was added as title #58
File 00482.m2ts was added as title #59
File 00484.m2ts was added as title #60
File 00486.m2ts was added as title #61
File 00487.m2ts was added as title #62
File 00488.m2ts was added as title #63
File 00489.m2ts was added as title #64
File 00490.m2ts was added as title #65
File 00496.m2ts was added as title #66
File 00500.m2ts was added as title #67
File 00501.m2ts was added as title #68
File 00502.m2ts was added as title #69
File 00513.m2ts was added as title #70
File 00514.m2ts was added as title #71
File 00515.m2ts was added as title #72
File 00517.m2ts was added as title #73
File 00518.m2ts was added as title #74
File 00526.m2ts was added as title #75
File 00527.m2ts was added as title #76
File 00528.m2ts was added as title #77
File 00532.m2ts was added as title #78
File 00546.m2ts was added as title #79
File 00573.m2ts was added as title #80
File 00580.m2ts was added as title #81
File 00585.m2ts was added as title #82
File 00600.m2ts was added as title #83
File 00601.m2ts was added as title #84
File 00602.m2ts was added as title #85
File 00603.m2ts was added as title #86
File 00604.m2ts was added as title #87
File 00605.m2ts was added as title #88
File 00606.m2ts was added as title #89
File 00607.m2ts was added as title #90
File 00608.m2ts was added as title #91
File 00609.m2ts was added as title #92
File 00610.m2ts was added as title #93
File 00611.m2ts was added as title #94
File 00619.m2ts was added as title #95
File 00620.m2ts was added as title #96
File 00621.m2ts was added as title #97
File 00622.m2ts was added as title #98
File 00624.m2ts was added as title #99
File 00625.m2ts was added as title #100
File 00629.m2ts was added as title #101
File 00632.m2ts was added as title #102
File 00633.m2ts was added as title #103
File 00634.m2ts was added as title #104
File 00635.m2ts was added as title #105
File 00637.m2ts was added as title #106
File 00640.m2ts was added as title #107
File 00641.m2ts was added as title #108
File 00642.m2ts was added as title #109
File 00643.m2ts was added as title #110
File 00644.m2ts was added as title #111
File 00645.m2ts was added as title #112
File 00647.m2ts was added as title #113
File 00648.m2ts was added as title #114
File 00649.m2ts was added as title #115
File 00654.m2ts was added as title #116
File 00655.m2ts was added as title #117
File 00656.m2ts was added as title #118
File 00659.m2ts was added as title #119
File 00660.m2ts was added as title #120
File 00661.m2ts was added as title #121
File 00662.m2ts was added as title #122
File 00663.m2ts was added as title #123
File 00664.m2ts was added as title #124
File 00665.m2ts was added as title #125
File 00666.m2ts was added as title #126
File 00667.m2ts was added as title #127
File 00668.m2ts was added as title #128
File 00669.m2ts was added as title #129
File 00671.m2ts was added as title #130
File 00672.m2ts was added as title #131
File 00673.m2ts was added as title #132
File 00674.m2ts was added as title #133
File 00675.m2ts was added as title #134
File 00676.m2ts was added as title #135
File 00677.m2ts was added as title #136
File 00678.m2ts was added as title #137
File 00679.m2ts was added as title #138
File 00680.m2ts was added as title #139
File 00681.m2ts was added as title #140
File 00682.m2ts was added as title #141
File 00683.m2ts was added as title #142
Title 00430.mpls(1) is equal to title 00430.mpls(5) and was skipped
Operation successfully completed

[Affrae]

Works fine here (same OS, same drive):

Code: Select all

MakeMKV v1.7.71 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/tim/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL MATSHITA DVD-R UJ-8A8 HB14" opened in DASPI v1.3 mode.
Optical drive "BD-RE HL-DT-ST BD-RE BH10LS30 1.01" opened in DASPI v1.3 mode.
Using direct disc access mode

...


Operation successfully completed

Thanks for checking - it might be a hardware issue at my end, then

Are you using an external case, or is this installed internally in a Mac Pro?

[Romansh]

External IcyBox USB 2.0 enclosure.

[Affrae]

External IcyBox USB 2.0 enclosure.

Thanks for responding.

Some further experimentation reveals that this is intermittent. I may have a hardware problem.

D.

[StefaanD]

Probably off-topic but i have no experience yet with BD ripping.

Is the LG BD-RE BH10LS30 the recommended drive for BD ripping or are there nowadays better options out there ? I use an iMac i7 3,4 GHz so would need an external one.

[Romansh]

All I can say is that it works, in my experience. I also have an ASUS SBC-06D1S-U as a backup, but it's slower (even than the LG with RipLock), and makes more noise.

[StefaanD]

Thanks, guess will be a bit harder to get my hands on the LG drive as it's discontinued.

The Samsung SE-506AB also seems to work, but slower reading speeds than the LG

[StefaanD]

Romash one last question, what Icy Box enclosure do you exactly, there seems millions of these

Is it the IB-550StU3S one ?

[Romansh]

No, it's an older one (USB 2.0 only). Not sure which one it is, TBH, but it looks the same as the one you linked to.

[StefaanD]

Then i guess it's this one, that's a USB 2.0 SATA internal but also contains a bracket for eSata not that we Mac users can do alot with that

Still have a very old Icy Box lying around here but only IDE inside no SATA so unusable i guess.

Also the LG BH10LS38 seems to be the successor to the BH10LS30. Gone check further how the compatibility is with Mac but already one positive report.