MakeMKV support forum
https://forum.makemkv.com/forum/
No, to the guy below, this isn't a conspiracy theory. What he's saying is likely the case. Meanwhile, my drive is still bricked and I'm never using Any DVD again. I'll trust over what I figured in theory, to begin with, over you just coming in and saying "no, that's not how things work" based on your theory of? Your cred of? You came into this with just shaking your head. I'm not trying to be rude, but that's not any help at all. This update on my theory of it is because I was using two other pieces of similar software (competition to MakeMKV) is very insightful, however, the reason that it just brought me to see your disapproval was a bit much. At the same time though, I did see this reply finally.htkrs wrote: ↑Fri Jun 18, 2021 6:53 pmHi, I believe using AnyDVD caused the drive to brick. Newer BD and UHD disks come with updated list of revoked host certificates which the drive copies into its flash memory when those disks are inserted. Perhaps you put a disk with newer AACS list and then AnyDVD presented a revoked AACS host certificate to the drive causing the drive to brick.
This post talks about AACS host revocation: viewtopic.php?p=70119#p70119
I see that one of your drives is flashed with LibreDrive. That surprises me because a feature of LibreDrive is to disable this host revocation.
Clean the disc and drive laser if that don't work it's dead.kdheslop@gmail.com wrote: ↑Sat Sep 18, 2021 4:51 pmWondering if any other updates on this? I have been using MakeMKV for 4-5 years now. May of 20 bought
Drive Information
Manufacturer: HL-DT-ST
Product: BD-RE WH16NS60
Revision: 1.00
Serial number: KL7K35A5447
Firmware date: 2117-04-25 17:56
Bus encryption flags: 17
Highest AACS version: 76
LibreDrive Information
Status: Enabled
Drive platform: MT1959
Firmware type: Original (unpatched)
Firmware version: 1.00
DVD all regions: Yes
BD raw data read: Yes
BD raw metadata read: Yes
Unrestricted read speed: Yes
No disc inserted
About two weeks ago started getting a "No Disk" message on one of three UHD disks used, now all UHD, DVD are reporting "no disk."
Send me the drives and I will fix free of charge, I feel sorry for all the hassle you have had. I will advise if parts are required. If you are based in Europe or the UK this would be okay.Someguy1234 wrote: ↑Sat May 01, 2021 6:27 amA SAD PERHAPS FINAL UPDATE:
WELL. I’m left using this older Blu-ray drive now and as a result, as a said before, my old drive seems to have been “bricked” in some way by using the DVDfab and/or AnyDVD HD software trial versions in conjunction with MakeMKV. Because, that drive now is just a “no disc” machine. It won’t even begin to read the disc and nothing will show up in for instance on Windows 10 for the disc under This PC listing all my drives. Usually it would at least load a title for both 4K UHD and the Blu-ray Discs inserted. Now it won’t even attempt to acknowledge anything has even been inserted into the disc tray via either Windows (PC) or even on a a Mac. It’s an external enclosure USB 3.0 drive with a power button, which I have used to try to reset the drive in Windows to no avail. I even went as far as to remove the drive in Windows in device manager, again with no luck. This is really getting me rather sad as I was using this drive a lot for primarily 4K discs. Now, I’m on a drive I have to only be able to access Blu-ray on. So, I need to find some way to figure out if this drive is indeed bricked, FUBAR, what have you, to the point it cannot be fixed even if someone were to flash the drive. It feels like I’m just going to have to end up finding a new drive from someone. Anyone up for the challenge of trying to help me here and fix this? I’ll be happy to pay someone to fix it or do a trade and pay you for a new drive, so that it can at least be used again by someone. I need 4K capabilities back and it seems something involving using the software I mentioned before has caused this. The drive was working perfectly fine before I installed those, yet the next day it never would read a thing again. Even in those softwares before I uninstalled them. My worry is that when I first used them as trials and uninstalled them, it saw I had MakeMKV and decided to also take note I had a drive with correct firmware to do 4K in hopes I’d turn to using their software. I know this sounds like some crackpot conspiracy theory but all I can tell you for sure is I have a drive that’s useless now, as far as I can tell and yeah… that’s pretty much where I’m at.
Thanks for reading this and I hope someone else can offer some sort of help. Feel free to private message me if you’re more comfortable with that.
I agree with Billy, likely Bluray laser gone. I would advise you to buy a new BU40N of Billy saying you are in the states and you have already been talking to him.
Make sure when you buy a drive that it is a 2021 model with latest hardware. I found this model LG BH16NS55.AUAR10B to give a lot of problems. The BH16NS55 drives I have are very reliable. In over 750 drives I have had 3 faulty.phileeny wrote: ↑Sun Oct 10, 2021 9:04 amI too have this problem of drive no longer reading discs.
I have two LG BH16NS55 drives, the first was down graded to 1.02 to read 4k Blu-rays and worked great for a long time, then it started to give me errors on 4k rips like.
Error 'Scsi error - ILLEGAL REQUEST:READ OF SCRAMBLED SECTOR WITHOUT AUTHENTICATION' occurred while reading
and hash errors like
Too many hash check errors in file 00055.m2ts. (always the main film file)
But DVDs and Blu-rays would rip fine, so I decided to get another LG BH16NS55 as a backup ripping drive just in case, this second drive came with firmware 1.04 but ripped 4k Blu-ray out of the box with LibreDrive.
Then one day months later the first drive didn't see a disc loaded, took it out and gave it a clean and it ripped fine, then it was hit and miss if the first drive would read a disc.
As of today the first drive will not detect any 4k Blu-ray or Blu-ray loaded with any software, I can hear it trying to read the disc then It says no disc, oddly DVD still read and rip fine.
The second drive reads and rips DVDs and Blu-rays fine but with 4k Blu-rays I always get a (Too many hash check errors in file...m2ts.) even on discs I've ripped fine before.
I'm going to remove the first drive and open it up and clean the laser with isopropanol.
I have seen the drive for sale as: