MakeMKV support forum
https://forum.makemkv.com/forum/
No issue on my end. I always demux both video layers and audio in one step. Hellboy 2019 played perfectly fine with the x700.deadchip12 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 12, 2020 7:10 pmIt is not advisable to demux both base layer and dolby vision layer at the same time right? As in we need to demux those one by one instead? I did that with Hellboy 2019 and it got massive stutter during playback.
Maybe it’s the issue with my hard drive. I will try moving the film to another hard drive. Is it ok to run the demuxing on an external hard drive? Is there any chance the hard drive will break because of that? I’m asking because my previous hard drive broke and the new one starts showing sign of slowness and I ran demuxing on both.RESET_9999 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 12, 2020 10:44 pmNo issue on my end. I always demux both video layers and audio in one step. Hellboy 2019 played perfectly fine with the x700.deadchip12 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 12, 2020 7:10 pmIt is not advisable to demux both base layer and dolby vision layer at the same time right? As in we need to demux those one by one instead? I did that with Hellboy 2019 and it got massive stutter during playback.
I do all my remux on an internal NVME m2 PCI-E drive because of the amazing speed and use a fast external USB 3.0 SSD drive for playback but I've experienced data writing issues with some cheap external USB enclosure. So yeah it could be a problem.deadchip12 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 13, 2020 9:44 amMaybe it’s the issue with my hard drive. I will try moving the film to another hard drive. Is it ok to run the demuxing on an external hard drive? Is there any chance the hard drive will break because of that? I’m asking because my previous hard drive broke and the new one starts showing sign of slowness and I ran demuxing on both.
Funnily enough, the hard drive with the issue here is a newer one with usb 3.0, while the one without issue is pretty old with only usb 2.0 I believe.RESET_9999 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 13, 2020 12:03 pmI do all my remux on an internal NVME m2 PCI-E drive because of the amazing speed and use a fast external USB 3.0 SSD drive for playback but I've experienced data writing issues with some cheap external USB enclosure. So yeah it could be a problem.deadchip12 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 13, 2020 9:44 amMaybe it’s the issue with my hard drive. I will try moving the film to another hard drive. Is it ok to run the demuxing on an external hard drive? Is there any chance the hard drive will break because of that? I’m asking because my previous hard drive broke and the new one starts showing sign of slowness and I ran demuxing on both.
You have to manually enable DV on the X700. It will display as such on the tv, but not be it necessarily. If you play back the same file from the tv chances are there is no DV trigger. Also, X700 cannot play Atmos from MKV TrueHD track.davin8r wrote:Has anyone else tried just ripping the main movie file (using MakeMKV or DVDFab 11) and playing that on the Sony x700? I've tried it on 2 UHD BluRays so far, and the x700 plays the movie file in both Dolby Vision *and* Atmos at the same time. Why bother to even convert to a different file container?
They're not talking about MKV. They're talking about leaving it in an m2ts file. I've wondered the same thing if it'd work or not but not enough to pull the x700 out of the other room to test it. The internal player on the tv doesn't support m2ts playback at all.bgalakazam wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 2:29 pmYou have to manually enable DV on the X700. It will display as such on the tv, but not be it necessarily. If you play back the same file from the tv chances are there is no DV trigger. Also, X700 cannot play Atmos from MKV TrueHD track.davin8r wrote:Has anyone else tried just ripping the main movie file (using MakeMKV or DVDFab 11) and playing that on the Sony x700? I've tried it on 2 UHD BluRays so far, and the x700 plays the movie file in both Dolby Vision *and* Atmos at the same time. Why bother to even convert to a different file container?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Dolby Vision Output is set to "on" in the Screen Settings and stays on (did you used to have to manually enable it for every movie?). Anyway, it's on, TV says it's using Dolby Vision (LG 2019 C series) and when I go to my TV's video settings it also says I'm in Dolby Vision. Also, Dolby Atmos is on via eARC.bgalakazam wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 2:29 pmYou have to manually enable DV on the X700. It will display as such on the tv, but not be it necessarily. If you play back the same file from the tv chances are there is no DV trigger. Also, X700 cannot play Atmos from MKV TrueHD track.davin8r wrote:Has anyone else tried just ripping the main movie file (using MakeMKV or DVDFab 11) and playing that on the Sony x700? I've tried it on 2 UHD BluRays so far, and the x700 plays the movie file in both Dolby Vision *and* Atmos at the same time. Why bother to even convert to a different file container?
SamuriHL wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 2:53 pmThey're not talking about MKV. They're talking about leaving it in an m2ts file. I've wondered the same thing if it'd work or not but not enough to pull the x700 out of the other room to test it. The internal player on the tv doesn't support m2ts playback at all.bgalakazam wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 2:29 pmYou have to manually enable DV on the X700. It will display as such on the tv, but not be it necessarily. If you play back the same file from the tv chances are there is no DV trigger. Also, X700 cannot play Atmos from MKV TrueHD track.davin8r wrote:Has anyone else tried just ripping the main movie file (using MakeMKV or DVDFab 11) and playing that on the Sony x700? I've tried it on 2 UHD BluRays so far, and the x700 plays the movie file in both Dolby Vision *and* Atmos at the same time. Why bother to even convert to a different file container?
I tried on some m2ts and on Lg C8 and Panasonic Gx810 I got DV triggered together with Atmos audio. Using the Sony X700 .SamuriHL wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 2:53 pmThey're not talking about MKV. They're talking about leaving it in an m2ts file. I've wondered the same thing if it'd work or not but not enough to pull the x700 out of the other room to test it. The internal player on the tv doesn't support m2ts playback at all.bgalakazam wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 2:29 pmYou have to manually enable DV on the X700. It will display as such on the tv, but not be it necessarily. If you play back the same file from the tv chances are there is no DV trigger. Also, X700 cannot play Atmos from MKV TrueHD track.davin8r wrote:Has anyone else tried just ripping the main movie file (using MakeMKV or DVDFab 11) and playing that on the Sony x700? I've tried it on 2 UHD BluRays so far, and the x700 plays the movie file in both Dolby Vision *and* Atmos at the same time. Why bother to even convert to a different file container?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
But this is where it gets tricky with the X700. Turning on DV sends the DV metadata for everything. So just triggering DV isn't enough of a test to know for SURE that it's truly playing DV content. Which is why I haven't bothered testing mine. Just seeing the DV logo on your display is meaningless and not a true test.
Hi there. I've found your posts r.e. the X700 very useful and am tempted to buy one.RESET_9999 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 13, 2020 12:03 pmI do all my remux on an internal NVME m2 PCI-E drive because of the amazing speed and use a fast external USB 3.0 SSD drive for playback but I've experienced data writing issues with some cheap external USB enclosure. So yeah it could be a problem.
exactly.Grencola wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 8:34 pmthis has all been answered multiple times earlier in this thread, but it's now massive though so I get it. the x700 only plays m2ts in hdr10, NOT dolby vision. the only thing (other than discs) that works in dolby vision is a dual-layer mp4 from both dlna and usb. this has been tested extensively. forcing dolby vision to ON, as stated above, applies a pseudo dv to all content and isn't real dolby vision. turning it off will still properly flag dv so long as the actual Metadata exists and your source content is correct.
Exactly! I'm using a USB thumb drive to play the M2ts file in the x700 (which I simply renamed "Dr_Sleep" or "The_Matrix", for instance). It works, and is *so* simple. No need for demuxing/remuxing, etc etc, just rip the main movie file and your backup is complete with both DV and DA preserved.
this is fake DV(probably similar to dvdfabs single layer remux) and the player OSD only show HDR while with UHD-BD and DV MP4, it says Dolby Vision HDR.They're not talking about MKV. They're talking about leaving it in an m2ts file. I've wondered the same thing if it'd work or not but not enough to pull the x700 out of the other room to test it. The internal player on the tv doesn't support m2ts playback at all.
Hi there. I've found your posts r.e. the X700 very useful and am tempted to buy one.
Something I'm puzzled by though (and touched upon above). Since the x700 does not auto switch into Dolby Vision, how do you know your MP4s etc are playing back with "true" dolby vision? I.e. if everything would be forced to dolby vision anyway?