Page 1 of 1
MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 11:45 am
by turtlegsr
Hi all,
i download just now this software and test with an italian DVD (L'albero deli zoccoli).
Conversion in mkv complete successfully in about 1h and i need to test with my xtreamer media player.
From forum i see that latest version was released at 4-mar-2010..more 1 year old
Is this project still in development?
Will be implemented in future compression feature for mkv creation?
I understand that real different between handbrake and this tool is full backup for media, correct?
For mkv file creation this tool at the moment is not capable to compress video, correct?
thanks
Marco
Re: MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 5:48 pm
by crowfax
That's when the post was created. Not the latest version. 1.6.16 came out about a month ago.
Re: MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:13 pm
by setarip_old
Will be implemented in future compression feature for mkv creation?
I understand that real different between handbrake and this tool is full backup for media, correct?
For mkv file creation this tool at the moment is not capable to compress video, correct?
1) MakeMKV's author has stated that there is NO intention of adding compression capability to MakeMKV (There are enough other programs already available.)
2) I've never used "Handbrake", but I don't believe it can create .MKV files from Blu-ray discs or DVDs...
Re: MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:42 pm
by SamuriHL
setarip_old wrote:
2) I've never used "Handbrake", but I don't believe it can create .MKV files from Blu-ray discs or DVDs...
From the handbrake website:
Supported Sources:
Most common multimedia files that libavformat and libavcodec support.
Any DVD or Bluray-like source which is NOT copy-protected. (removal of copy protection is not supported)
Outputs:
File format: MP4(M4V) and MKV
Video: MPEG-4(ffmpeg), H.264(x264), or Theora(libtheora)
Audio: AAC, CoreAudio AAC (OS X Only), MP3, or Vorbis. AC-3 pass-through, DTS pass-thorugh (MKV only)
I haven't used Handbrake in a while (as I have no need for compression) but it looks like it can handle creating MKV's.
Re: MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 11:38 pm
by setarip_old
@SamuriHL
Hi!
Can "Handbrake" also rip commercial discs?
Re: MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 11:52 pm
by joe42
setarip_old wrote:
Can "Handbrake" also rip commercial discs?
Not if they are copy-protected. You'd need to remove the copy protection first, using something like MakeMKV or AnyDVD.
Re: MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Wed Nov 16, 2011 12:51 am
by setarip_old
Not if they are copy-protected.
That's what I thought - and that explain why users constantly talking about Handbrake still (have to) use MakeMKV (The only "one click to rip and convert to .MKV first)...
Re: MakeMKV release plan and update
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2011 1:41 am
by SamuriHL
setarip_old wrote:Not if they are copy-protected.
That's what I thought - and that explain why users constantly talking about Handbrake still (have to) use MakeMKV (The only "one click to rip and convert to .MKV first)...
That's correct, yes. Obviously they can use any decrypter in the Handbrake workflow. Personally, I find MakeMKV to be the best MKV creation utility on the market. I have no need or desire to alter the original stream quality. That's also the heart of my persistent request to be able to default the audio tracks to HD audio, but, that's another topic altogether. In any case, yea, Handbrake can handle non-protected DVD/BD structures, but, they do need to be decrypted first.