Naming and ordering of HD DVD titles
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2011 1:50 pm
Hi.
I've finally started ripping my HD DVDs with MakeMKV, and I've noticed that MakeMKV gets the names wrong if there's a "play all" option that the title is part of.
Here's a simplified excerpt from the VPLST000.XPL of the Galapagos HD DVD.
<Title titleNumber="3" id="MainMovie" displayName="PlayAll">...</Title>
<Title titleNumber="4" id="Episode1" displayName="Episode1">...</Title>
<Title titleNumber="5" id="Episode2" displayName="Episode2">...</Title>
<Title titleNumber="6" id="Episode3" displayName="Episode3">...</Title>
This results in the files:
t00_PlayAll.mkv
t04_PlayAll.mkv
t05_PlayAll.mkv
It turns out that title 5 is episode 1, title 0 is episode 2 and title 4 is episode 3
I have the same problem with deleted scenes, if there's a "play all" option there. All files will be named "play all" instead of the actual name of the scene.
I also think it would be useful to be able to choose if you want to rip the "play all" title, or the individual titles. When I rip a TV-series, I'd like to have the episodes individually, but in the case of special features, like deleted scenes, I usually prefer to have it as one file with chapters, instead of many small files. In the GUI, the individual titles could be placed as sub-items under the "play all"-item. This would be expanded by default, with the individual titles selected, and the "play all" title unselected.
I've finally started ripping my HD DVDs with MakeMKV, and I've noticed that MakeMKV gets the names wrong if there's a "play all" option that the title is part of.
Here's a simplified excerpt from the VPLST000.XPL of the Galapagos HD DVD.
<Title titleNumber="3" id="MainMovie" displayName="PlayAll">...</Title>
<Title titleNumber="4" id="Episode1" displayName="Episode1">...</Title>
<Title titleNumber="5" id="Episode2" displayName="Episode2">...</Title>
<Title titleNumber="6" id="Episode3" displayName="Episode3">...</Title>
This results in the files:
t00_PlayAll.mkv
t04_PlayAll.mkv
t05_PlayAll.mkv
It turns out that title 5 is episode 1, title 0 is episode 2 and title 4 is episode 3
I have the same problem with deleted scenes, if there's a "play all" option there. All files will be named "play all" instead of the actual name of the scene.
I also think it would be useful to be able to choose if you want to rip the "play all" title, or the individual titles. When I rip a TV-series, I'd like to have the episodes individually, but in the case of special features, like deleted scenes, I usually prefer to have it as one file with chapters, instead of many small files. In the GUI, the individual titles could be placed as sub-items under the "play all"-item. This would be expanded by default, with the individual titles selected, and the "play all" title unselected.