Page 1 of 1
Tried ripping a BR disc with V1.17.6- system rebooted
Posted: Fri Mar 15, 2024 11:03 pm
by cappy2112
I'm on MacOS 11.7.10 (20G1427) with a M1 MacMini.
I tried ripping a BR disc, which eventually failed.
I then cleaned the disc and tried ripping it again- my system rebooted.
A crash dump wasn't displayed though.
Are there any logs I can post for the developers?
Re: Tried ripping a BR disc with V1.17.6- system rebooted
Posted: Sat Mar 16, 2024 4:15 am
by dcoke22
It is my observation from using MakeMKV on a Mac that Apple is slowly letting macOS's support for optical discs rot. It seems that in those bits of the macOS filesystem there are lots of unhandled exceptions that cause a kernel panic. When that happens, the Mac will reboot.
Problematic discs seem to be the most likely thing to cause this to happen, especially when trying to cancel out of a rip that's going sideways.
Re: Tried ripping a BR disc with V1.17.6- system rebooted
Posted: Sun Mar 17, 2024 4:55 am
by cappy2112
I wasn’t trying to cancel out a bad rip. The rip had ended showing “FAILED”. I clicked OK to
Close the dialog and tried again.
That’s when the Mac rebooted.
Chances are it’s also a bug in the app- not checking a return value, not making sure a pointer is valid before using it.
Makemkv has plenty of problems, even though it’s ImProved over time. For one- you cannot cancel
Out of a rip- it just doesn’t acknowledge the cancel button. Very bad
Re: Tried ripping a BR disc with V1.17.6- system rebooted
Posted: Fri Mar 29, 2024 12:22 pm
by dmdmmatt4
I disagree, application errors don't cause kernel panics. Kernel errors cause kernel panics..
I realise makemkv uses some low level device commands at times but that's no excuse for the kernel to panic. Take the complaint to Apple.