Problematic HD-DVDs

[cozzmo]

Still no audio on coverted HD-DVD's with 1.6.2 (video fine) (same previous examples .. Cat People and Forbidden Planet)

I tried to confirm Forbidden Planet, went to rip it and the disc isn't readable anymore even stops in my XE1 player. Very annoyed!

[SamuriHL]

Still no audio on coverted HD-DVD's with 1.6.2 (video fine) (same previous examples .. Cat People and Forbidden Planet)

I tried to confirm Forbidden Planet, went to rip it and the disc isn't readable anymore even stops in my XE1 player. Very annoyed!

It's an EXTREMELY poorly made disc. I was never able to rip mine brand new out of the package. Fortunately I only paid a couple bucks for it, but, I could never rip it.

[dougnliz]

Any idea why I can't get 5.1 Audio on my HD-DVD rips? Blu-Ray is working just fine.

I get audio, just not 5.1. So far I've tried:

Hollywoodland
Flag of our Fathers

[scurrilous]

1 )Batman Begins
2) WB
3) VC-1
4) TrueHD 5.1
5) Fails about 2/3 of the way through, culd be the disc it looks like layers might be seperating (Like Laserot on laserdiscs)

This one worked for me with 1.6.2, though I only took the DD 3/2+1 audio track.

[scurrilous]

1) Top Gun
2) Paramount
3) mpeg4
4) TrueHD 5.1, DTS 3/2+1
5) Stops at 8961.8mb each time. Disc has been cleaned & checked.
6) Debug log below:

Same here:

1) Top Gun
2) Paramount
3) Mpeg4
4) TrueHD 5.1, DTS 3/2+1, DDplus 3/2+1
5) "LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input" @ 9265.9M
6) Debug log:

Code: Select all

Debug log started at Sat Nov 27 19:04:37 2010 , written by MakeMKV v1.6.2 win(x64-release)
Using 524544KB for read cache.
001005:0000 MakeMKV v1.6.2 win(x64-release) started
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at :e4{WP42AE'=sH_(z:121262164
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at :e4{WP42AE'=sH_(z:121262164
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at :e4{WP42AE'=sH_(z:121262164
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at :e4{WP42AE'=sH_(z:121262164
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 989 at se#Wjk$|<_4^GI!MuC-~~:213132974
005011:0000 Operation successfully completed
005014:0000 Saving 1 titles into directory H:/Video/MKV/TOPGUN
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 7 at y#>Yi%z%z~MEKjBQ1lk^:121264050
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at se#Wjk$|<_4^GI!MuC-~~:29397449
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at 4,O:||lWA!BpRtH9bS\:121263751
FS ID=V_MPEG4/ISO/AVC C=2
TI=ZeNpjZICCHbYOjAyYYIHKAWUQbcVAOmhgZ2CwYEHQBqUMDC+ZGRiYINICIPsAi04GQw==
C_00000=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
C_00001=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
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at se#Wjk$|<_4^GI!MuC-~~:29397449
001003:0020 DEBUG: Code 0 at f<4)_m: 6*i(F?'E[`':213133204
001002:0020 LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
005003:0000 Failed to save title 0 to file H:/Video/MKV/TOPGUN/t00_Main_Movie.mkv
005004:0080 0 titles saved, 1 failed
005037:0204 Copy complete. 0 titles saved, 1 failed.

Tried it multiple times with same result. DVDFab HD 4 can rip it without error, but then I get an HVDVD_TS which nothing will play directly. Almost converted the HVDVD_TS to MKV with eac3to, but there's an audio sync issue I've been unable to resolve. (Point is: Disc and drive are known to work.)

[scurrilous]

Stardust
Paramount
Mpeg4
DDplus
Failed to save title 1 to file
DEBUG: Code 7 at ML7guqhKk;owG;\JTr>*:121264050
DEBUG: Code 0 at o$RAsAp!bG*A&KNptG\;':29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at g*_tFMoQkzW[<oWsU\$:121263751
DEBUG: Code 0 at o$RAsAp!bG*A&KNptG\;':29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at kO55^bs+-=`<^:&z>(W:213133204
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input

Same here. Didn't having logging enabled, but can try again with logging if that helps.

[alkie4life]

1) Pan's Labyrinth
2) Newline
3) VC-1
4) DTS-HD
5) Failed to open disc

MakeMKV v1.6.2 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/andrewdittrich/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL OPTIARC DVD RW AD-5680H 3AHB" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Optical drive "BD-ROM TOSHIBA DVD/HD X807616 MC08" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Evaluation version, 27 day(s) out of 30 remaining
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at K's>a>22^>sd-:29393654
Failed to open disc

[alkie4life]

1) Transformers
2) Paramount
3) Mpeg4
4) DDplus3/2+1
5) Failed to save

MakeMKV v1.6.2 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/andrewdittrich/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL OPTIARC DVD RW AD-5680H 3AHB" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Optical drive "BD-ROM TOSHIBA DVD/HD X807616 MC08" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Evaluation version, 27 day(s) out of 30 remaining
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
Operation successfully completed
Saving 1 titles into directory /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop
DEBUG: Code 7 at Wtv?uH,n)- I)]a\KZ~k:121264050
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at HZqedXoW1w{J' +4$?b:121263751
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at {,H:D_3xF=[q72s4QHX:213133204
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 2 to file /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop/t02_Main_Movie.mkv
0 titles saved, 1 failed

[alkie4life]

1) Babel
2) Paramount
3) Mpeg4
4) DDplus3/2+1
5) Failed to save

MakeMKV v1.6.2 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/andrewdittrich/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL OPTIARC DVD RW AD-5680H 3AHB" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Optical drive "BD-ROM TOSHIBA DVD/HD X807616 MC08" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Evaluation version, 26 day(s) out of 30 remaining
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
Operation successfully completed
Saving 1 titles into directory /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop
DEBUG: Code 7 at Wtv?uH,n)- I)]a\KZ~k:121264050
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at HZqedXoW1w{J' +4$?b:121263751
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at {,H:D_3xF=[q72s4QHX:213133204
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 1 to file /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop/t01_Main_Movie.mkv
0 titles saved, 1 failed

[alkie4life]

1) Into the Wild
2) Paramount
3) Mpeg4
4) DDplus3/2+1
5) Failed to save

MakeMKV v1.6.2 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/andrewdittrich/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL OPTIARC DVD RW AD-5680H 3AHB" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Optical drive "BD-ROM TOSHIBA DVD/HD X807616 MC08" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Evaluation version, 26 day(s) out of 30 remaining
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
Operation successfully completed
Saving 1 titles into directory /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop
DEBUG: Code 7 at Wtv?uH,n)- I)]a\KZ~k:121264050
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at HZqedXoW1w{J' +4$?b:121263751
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at {,H:D_3xF=[q72s4QHX:213133204
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 1 to file /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop/t01_Main_Movie.mkv
0 titles saved, 1 failed

[alkie4life]

1) Black Snake Moan
2) Paramount
3) Mpeg4
4) DDplus3/2+1
5) Failed to save

MakeMKV v1.6.2 darwin(x86-release) started
Debug logging enabled, log will be saved as /Users/andrewdittrich/MakeMKV_log.txt
Optical drive "DVD+R-DL OPTIARC DVD RW AD-5680H 3AHB" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Optical drive "BD-ROM TOSHIBA DVD/HD X807616 MC08" opened in OS access mode.
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
DEBUG: Code 3758097095 at 3AX-9OJBHPgW>vPgYt9DWHq]'Jw?:29394919
Evaluation version, 26 day(s) out of 30 remaining
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
DEBUG: Code 0 at l.>R$7^QzFzH/W,s}:121262164
Operation successfully completed
Saving 1 titles into directory /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop
DEBUG: Code 7 at Wtv?uH,n)- I)]a\KZ~k:121264050
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at HZqedXoW1w{J' +4$?b:121263751
DEBUG: Code 0 at ^GR>u(ewS%2yJq6}V)P'2:29397449
DEBUG: Code 0 at {,H:D_3xF=[q72s4QHX:213133204
LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input
Failed to save title 1 to file /Users/andrewdittrich/Desktop/t01_Main_Movie.mkv
0 titles saved, 1 failed

[alkie4life]

Just posted my 5 problem discs. This is out of 32 attempts so overall great software! I'll definitely be purchasing! I hope we can get these last ones resolved as then I'll be 100% HD-DVD free, which is good since my LG BH200 is on the fritz. Thanks for the thread!

[setarip_old]

@alkie4life

Hi!

I'd suggest you try to carefully and thoroughly clean all 5 of your problematic discs - and I'd look for physical damage on "Pan's Labyrinth", particularly near the inner ring and outer edge of the disc.

Let us know if these suggestions yield any positive results...

[alkie4life]

@alkie4life

Hi!

I'd suggest you try to carefully and thoroughly clean all 5 of your problematic discs - and I'd look for physical damage on "Pan's Labyrinth", particularly near the inner ring and outer edge of the disc.

Let us know if these suggestions yield any positive results...

Cleaned and inspected them all, tried each again. Same result. Into the Wild and Black Snake Moan are the only "new" additions to this thread. The other three other users had issues with as well.

Let me know if I can help testany potential fixes/changes. Thanks!

[goingbust]

I am having trouble with Payback: Straight Up and Black Snake Moan

Code: Select all

MakeMKV v1.6.2 win(x64-release) started
Operation successfully completed
Saving 9 titles into directory G:/Video/PAYBACK_DIRECTORS_CUT
Failed to save title 0 to file G:/Video/PAYBACK_DIRECTORS_CUT/t00_Main_Movie.mkv
Failed to save title 4 to file G:/Video/PAYBACK_DIRECTORS_CUT/t04_MAINMENU.mkv
7 titles saved, 2 failed
Operation successfully completed
Saving 16 titles into directory G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN
Failed to save title 0 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t00_menu_video.mkv
Failed to save title 1 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t01_Main_Movie.mkv
Failed to save title 2 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t02_Trailer.mkv
Failed to save title 4 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t04_PARALOGO.mkv
Failed to save title 5 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t05_menu_video.mkv
Failed to save title 6 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t06_menu_video.mkv
Failed to save title 8 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t08_deleted_scenes_play_all.mkv
Failed to save title 9 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t09_deleted_scenes_play_all.mkv
Failed to save title 10 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t10_deleted_scenes_play_all.mkv
Failed to save title 11 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t11_deleted_scenes_play_all.mkv
Failed to save title 12 to file G:/Video/BLACKSNAKEMOAN/t12_deleted_scenes_play_all.mkv
5 titles saved, 11 failed

I did Face/Off, The Kingdom, and Smokin' Aces with no problem.