WHy are half of the VOB not working in MakeMKV?

[mrgenie]

DELETED, KGB CENSORED

[Smithcraft]

We might have an iDea if you posted a log of what happened on one of these discs.

SC

[twa000]

Around 50% of all the vob files error in makeMKV.
Only MakeMKV errors on 500 out of 1000 DVD's (or files)
any idea why this program is so incompatible with half of every media
I own?

You don't say what are the error(s) - If this was typical all users would be screaming, so it is something in your setup, so you need to send some files for examination from a named original DVD (not a copy)

[Chetwood]

Exactly. 100% of my VOB files are working.

[mrgenie]

DELETED, KGB CENSORED

[mrgenie]

DELETED, KGB CENSORED

[mrgenie]

DELETED, KGB CENSORED

[setarip_old]

@mrgenie

Hi!

MakeMKV errors on 500 out of 1000 DVD's (or files)

Saving 2 titles into directory C:/Users/Vincent/Downloads

LIBMKV_TRACE: Exception: Error while reading input

Based on the three items I've quoted from your posts to this thread, it seems that some of your source material is other than commercial DVDs and may not be "perfect". If this is, in fact, the case, it would be an exercise in futility to try and speculate what's causing your remarkable claimed failure rate. As suggested in an earlier response to you by another member, if MakeMKV exhibited such a failure rate (which it most certainly doesn't), it would very quickly cease to exist (which it hasn't)...

[mrgenie]

DELETED, KGB CENSORED

[mrgenie]

DELETED, KGB CENSORED

[mrgenie]

Moderator. Please close and delete this thread.

Obviously no one wants to help other people other then saying they are lying and makeMKV is perfect and errors do not exist!
So there's no need to ask for help here, KGB is on top of me the moment I say I have a severe problem and no one willing to help with it..

so censor and remove it, to stay in line with the KGB.

[Chetwood]

Lying, my ass. If I say 100% of my VOBs work perfect, it does not imply that MakeMKV is perfect.

[setarip_old]

@mrgenie

Obviously no one wants to help other people other then saying they are lying

That's a silly statement to make. All you have to do is look at the THOUSANDS of positive, helpful posts that have been made at this forum since its inception to see that what you've stated is not the case.

From what I've observed, this forum has some of the most knowledgable users and testers of makeMKV, who are more than happy to share this knowledge as part of the advancement of MakeMKV while it's still in beta testing.

BTW - What have you accomplished by deleting your original posts to this thread?

Peace be with you...

[Smithcraft]

DELETED, KGB CENSORED

Now that's funny!

SC