USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE FRUSTRATING MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
ONE INSTANCE OF MAKEMKV SHOULD NOT BE ABLE TO INTERRUPT ANOTHER INSTANCE!!
I pull in 3 disks at once. MakeMKV's.is so dumb when it comes to dealing with multiple instances.
First of all, if i already have TWO drives, each being used by MakeMKV to pull data off of discs, and i launch a 3rd instance, that third instance seems to be completely UNAWARE of the other TWO instances, and just interrupts those TWO WORKING drives to poll the drives -- this almost always INTERRUPTS and kills those jobs with "Error 'Scsi error - MEDIUM ERROR:L-EC UNCORRECTABLE ERROR' occurred while reading '/VIDEO_TS/VTS_01_1.VOB' at offset "
This is SO DUMB!!! I keep losing work and experiencing SETBACKS. Why on earth doesn't each instance of MakeMKV check to see if tne other instances are engaged with drives first. Also, every time i launch an instance it polls ALL THREE DRIVES! I don't want the instance to automatically poll ANYTHING!! This keeps ruining productivity. I want the software to launch, and do NOTHING. I want to select the drive MANUALLY.
This is so frustrating. Imagine trying to ingest 15 years worth of a show with 300+ episodes, and over a hundred special features, and the tasks keep failing because MakeMKV won't stop interfering with itself!
How do i make the instances STOP polling ALL drives at launch??!!
Often when this happens, i cannot get an instance to see a disc again until i QUIT that instance and re-launch it -- but then that interferes with already running instances by stupidly polling ALL drives again -- interrupting running jobs.
This is TERRIBLE.
Make it so when an new instance launches, i can DISABLE AUTOMATIC POLLING, and MANUALLY SELECT a DRIVE/DISC!!!
USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE FRUSTRATING MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE FRUSTRATING MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
Last edited by etyrnal on Thu Dec 25, 2025 12:14 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE STUPID MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
In MakeMKV preferences > IO tab > check 'Ask for single drive mode' & try again.etyrnal wrote: ↑Wed Dec 24, 2025 11:10 pmUSING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE STUPID MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
ONE INSTANCE OF MAKEMKV SHOULD NOT BE ABLE TO INTERRUPT ANOTHER INSTANCE!!
I pull in 3 disks at once. MakeMKV's.is so dumb when it comes to dealing with multiple instances.
First of all, if i already have TWO drives, each being used by MakeMKV to pull data off of discs, and i launch a 3rd instance, that third instance seems to be completely UNAWARE of the other TWO instances, and just interrupts those TWO WORKING drives to poll the drives -- this almost always INTERRUPTS and kills those jobs with "Error 'Scsi error - MEDIUM ERROR:L-EC UNCORRECTABLE ERROR' occurred while reading '/VIDEO_TS/VTS_01_1.VOB' at offset "
This is SO DUMB!!! I keep losing work and experiencing SETBACKS. Why on earth doesn't each instance of MakeMKV check to see if tne other instances are engaged with drives first. Also, every time i launch an instance it polls ALL THREE DRIVES! I don't want the instance to automatically poll ANYTHING!! This keeps ruining productivity. I want the software to launch, and do NOTHING. I want to select the drive MANUALLY.
This is so frustrating. Imagine trying to ingest 15 years worth of a show with 300+ episodes, and over a hundred special features, and the tasks keep failing because MakeMKV won't stop interfering with itself!
How do i make the instances STOP polling ALL drives at launch??!!
Often when this happens, i cannot get an instance to see a disc again until i QUIT that instance and re-launch it -- but then that interferes with already running instances by stupidly polling ALL drives again -- interrupting running jobs.
This is TERRIBLE.
Make it so when an new instance launches, i can DISABLE AUTOMATIC POLLING, and MANUALLY SELECT a DRIVE/DISC!!!
Re: USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE STUPID MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
Re: USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE STUPID MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
When that option is checked, each instance of MakeMKV you launch will ask which ODD you'd like to bind to that instance & not interfere w/ others. Not much of a risk in just trying it, is there?
Re: USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE STUPID MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
the risk was loosing time.
i tried it. it works well. except for when i eject finished discs, it seems like the binding is lost or something and an instance can land on the wrong ODD again. Like the instance does not STAY exclusively on that one ODD.
Re: USING THREE OPTICAL DRIVES IS A PAIN BECAUSE OF AVOIDABLE FRUSTRATING MAKEMKV BEHAVIOR
I've been using this mode for years, and (so far) up to 4 drives in use. Each instance stays bound to its drive, IF YOU REMEMBER TO DO SO at start-up.
It would be nice if you could set up shortcuts to do the auto-bind, but...
It would be nice if you could set up shortcuts to do the auto-bind, but...
MakeMKV Frequently Asked Questions
FAQ about BETA and PERMANENT keys.
How to aid in finding the answer to your problem: Activating Debug Logging
FAQ about BETA and PERMANENT keys.
How to aid in finding the answer to your problem: Activating Debug Logging