www.makemkv.com

Thanks for fixing that, mike.

Can you maybe name another affected title (except Avatar)? So that it can be re-ripped properly with the 1.7.7 version?

MakeMKV not working anymore.

Is there a new beta key?

Got it! It worked with the 4.0.1 Java version of BDSup2Sub. Seems like the exe port still has some problems. I'll try to inform the author. Thanks guys!

Thanks for the suggestion but it's not working using BDSup2Sub (.exe version). I have demuxed the english PGS subtitles (from my Original BD) using TSMuxeR to a normal (BD) SUP file. When I open that file in BDSup2Sub.exe it already shows "246 warnings" when loading. When trying to export ...

Until this problem is fixed on MakeMKV's side, is there a tool which can be used to *properly* get Avatar's forced subs out of the main subtitle stream into an extra stream?

Thanks in advance.

Hi all, what I really would like to know:

Is there another Blu-ray disc where this particular subtitle-problem occurs (except Avatar)?

I also just stumbled over this MakeMKV-related Avatar forced subs bug. Hope this gets fixed sometime. Cheers.

Avatar Extended Cut R2/B Blu-ray MakeMKV has no problem with extracting the forced subs into an extra stream, as always. But when playing back the MKV the forced subtitles don't turn off, they always stay on-screen until another forced subtitle comes up! This leads to some subtitles displayed on-scr...

Yes, MPC-HC is perfect for MKVs with PGS subtitles. No problems at all. With hardware players it is a little different: I still have to find one which supports PGS subs in MKV files 100% problem-free. I really don't understand the situation, as PGS subtitles are the Blu-ray *standard* and should be ...

Thanks for all the info, crowfax. OK, since the WD Live player has that strange PGS zlib limitation it is out of the question for me. I want a player that works 100% reliable (subtitle-wise) this time. About the Xtreamer Sidewinder 3: Interesting player, but does it display PGS subtitles in MKV corr...

Hi everybody, which (Hardware)-Multimedia-Player is the best when it comes to *perfect* MKV playback on a LCD/LED TV with flawless PGS subtitle support? I currently own a Popcorn Hour A-210 which plays all my MKVs without any problems but it has a serious PGS subtitle problem. It displays them but t...

Thanks for explaining the "logic" behind that. But still: IF an audio delay of -56ms is set by MakeMKV, do I have to rely on my player now to obey the "Audio delay relative to video" value and correct the sync accordingly? Will the movie be out of sync if my hardware MKV player i...

Hi mike,

of course I will send you the files.

Please let me know what tool you want me to use for cutting the files. I'm using Win7 64bit.

Cheers, S.

Thank god, I'm not alone with that strange problem.

OK, I will try that. Thanks for the tip!

Hi all, when I use MMG's Header Editor or mkvpropedit on a MKV created from a DVD the MKV header gets totally changed. The file isn't playable anymore with my tool of choice MPC-HC ("Cannot render file"). I just want to change one subtitle default flag. I do this very often with MKVs made ...