www.makemkv.com

A little followup here: I copied all the files on the blu-ray to a local disk, and then ran makeMKV on the BDMV file. This actually worked. It's obviously an extra step, but good to know it's possible to get it to work. But now the MKV files are sitting on my NAS and the lovely Atmos audio plays gre...

I can't get makemkv to open the disc at all. Says "This disc uses newer version of AACS protection." and ultimately "Failed to open disc."

I currently own an LG WH16NS40 that I successfully flashed and it's been working fine, ripped movies like Furiosa and The Matrix without issue. But it cannot read any of the Lord of the Rings 4k discs, presumably because these are triple-layer. It doesn't even log an error, it just spins the disc fo...