www.makemkv.com

Doing the above has allowed me to finally get the Forced Subtitles on Avatar, Avengers Assemble and Charlie's Angels, thus far. So the 3 Disc Collector's edition has no items flagged as forced as opposed to the regular US BD of Avatar which is one of the very few US BDs that has been authored this ...

AVGeek99 wrote: ↑

Wed Feb 19, 2025 6:36 am

Is there a simple way to identify which of the subtitle tracks should be marked as forced?

Play back the movie in VLC an enable a subtitle track. If someone is speaking and there's no subitle shown, it's most like the forced track.

ripthem wrote: ↑

Fri Jan 24, 2025 9:36 pm

I want all videos track, all german and english audio and subtitle tracks.

Me too, which is why I use this: -sel:all,+sel:(deu|eng|nolang),-sel:(core),-10:(forced*(eng)),-15:(deu),-20:(forced*(deu)).

Since Vobsub uses less colors than PGS, you usually do lose a bit of quality but it's usually acceptable. Since PGS are better/bigger, they are easier to OCR than Vobsub, so I personally always go with SRT. Losing positioning doesn't matter that much IMO.

Oops, I keep English and German subs only so and apparently I've adjusted my command badly above. If you wand to keep only all English subs, this should do it: -sel:all,+sel:(eng),-sel:(core),-10:(eng),-20:(forced(eng) The "lighter" tracks rise to the top, that means the English forced (IF...

Should look something like this: -sel:all,+sel:(eng),-sel:(core),-10:(eng),-20:(forced*(eng).

Sounds like too much work to implement for Mike when he won't even implement some kind of parse function like BDtoAVCHD's 'Scan bitrate'. After parsing is done, it shows each track's size so you can pinpoint the forced tracks easily without having to extract them first. If it detects items flagged a...

It's been quite a while but IIRC DVD Shrink also strips region coding. You could give it a go.

If all else fails you could remove those with mkvpropedit.

I ask this as sometimes these subs are not on their own "stream/track" but a subset that has to be fished out as it were. Usually these subsets are items which are forced which is exactly what MakeMKV will recognize and extract as a single track of only forced subs. The problem is with se...

What picture?

Have you set minimum title length to something like 40 minutes under Preferences > Video? That should get rid of most of the fluff. You might still end up with some specials so better check the runtime and tracks before starting the ripping process.

However, when it does detect that there are forced subtitles, why didn't it mark that track as forced automatically? Why did I have to go into MKVToolNix No idea but for many players it's aparrently enough to set it to default which MakeMKV does by setting setFirstForcedSubtitleTrackAsDefault="...

There's not even any way to view their size (looking for empty subtitles). As mentioned before, opening the disc in BDtoAVCHD > scan bitrates detects forced subtitles by size which works rather well. That's much quicker than watching the movie and trying to scan through searching for foreign langua...

And how do you suppose would MakeMKV know if there's forced items in the last 10 minutes of a movie without actually parsing the entire file upfront?